I have retrieved core surgical indications from Bailey & Love's. I'll now synthesize a comprehensive answer from this plus my own detailed clinical knowledge.
Haemorrhoids: Study and Surgical Management
1. Anatomy and Pathophysiology
Normal Anal Cushions
The anal canal contains three primary vascular cushions located at the 3, 7, and 11 o'clock positions (with the patient in the lithotomy position). These are normal structures composed of:
- Arteriovenous communications (branches of the superior rectal artery)
- Smooth muscle (Treitz muscle) and connective tissue that anchors cushions to the internal sphincter
- Overlying mucosa/anoderm
Haemorrhoids develop when these cushions engorge, prolapse, and the supporting connective tissue (Parks' ligament) weakens. The sliding anal lining theory (Thomson, 1975) is the most accepted — downward displacement of cushions due to straining and weakening of supporting tissue.
Venous Drainage Significance
- Above dentate line → superior rectal vein → portal system
- Below dentate line → inferior rectal veins → systemic (pudendal → IVC)
This determines the nerve supply and thus pain sensitivity:
- Internal haemorrhoids (above dentate line): visceral innervation — painless unless strangulated
- External haemorrhoids (below dentate line): somatic innervation — painful
2. Classification
By Anatomical Origin
| Type | Origin | Innervation | Characteristics |
|---|
| Internal | Above dentate line | Visceral (ANS) | Painless bleeding, prolapse |
| External | Below dentate line | Somatic | Painful, perianal lump |
| Mixed (interno-external) | Both zones | Both | Combined features |
Degree Classification of Internal Haemorrhoids (Goligher's System)
| Degree | Description | Clinical Significance |
|---|
| 1st degree | Bleed only; do not prolapse | Conservative/injection treatment |
| 2nd degree | Prolapse on straining but reduce spontaneously | Banding / conservative |
| 3rd degree | Prolapse and require manual reduction | Banding or surgery |
| 4th degree | Permanently prolapsed, irreducible | Surgery mandatory |
Strangulated haemorrhoids are a subtype of 4th degree where prolapsed tissue has its blood supply cut off — a surgical emergency.
3. Aetiology and Risk Factors
- Chronic constipation / straining at stool
- Low-fibre diet
- Prolonged sitting (especially on the toilet)
- Pregnancy and puerperium (raised intra-abdominal pressure)
- Portal hypertension (cavernous haemorrhoids — special consideration)
- Chronic diarrhoea / IBS
- Hereditary connective tissue weakness
- Obesity
- Aging (progressive connective tissue degeneration)
4. Clinical Features
Symptoms
- Painless bright red rectal bleeding (BRBPR) — hallmark; blood on paper, coating stool, or dripping into pan
- Prolapse — sensation of lump/tissue per anum
- Mucus discharge and perianal soiling
- Pruritus ani
- Discomfort/heaviness — not true pain unless complicated
- Pain — only with:
- Strangulation
- Thrombosed external haemorrhoid
- Co-existing fissure
Signs on Examination
Inspection (perianal): Skin tags (residua of previous haemorrhoids), prolapsed haemorrhoids, thrombosed external haemorrhoid (tense, purplish, tender)
Digital rectal examination (DRE): Haemorrhoids are NOT palpable normally (soft, compressible). DRE is done to exclude other pathology (rectal carcinoma, polyps)
Proctoscopy (essential):
- Confirms internal haemorrhoids
- Identifies position, degree, and active bleeding points
- Performed at rest and with straining
5. Investigations
Mandatory
| Investigation | Purpose |
|---|
| Proctoscopy | Confirms diagnosis, grades haemorrhoids |
| Full blood count | Assess anaemia from chronic blood loss |
Indicated (to exclude other pathology)
| Investigation | Indication |
|---|
| Flexible sigmoidoscopy | Patient >40 years, suspicious features, change in bowel habit |
| Colonoscopy | Family history colorectal cancer, iron-deficiency anaemia, right-sided symptoms, inadequate sigmoidoscopy |
| Barium enema / CT colonography | Alternative to colonoscopy if unavailable |
| LFTs / Clotting screen | If portal hypertension suspected |
| Prothrombin time, platelet count | Before any intervention |
Important: Rectal bleeding must NEVER be attributed to haemorrhoids without excluding colorectal malignancy, especially in patients >40 years or with red-flag features.
6. Differential Diagnosis
| Condition | Key Distinguishing Features |
|---|
| Colorectal carcinoma | Change in bowel habit, dark/altered blood, weight loss, mass on DRE |
| Rectal prolapse | Full-thickness circumferential prolapse with concentric mucosal folds |
| Rectal polyp | May bleed, diagnosed on endoscopy |
| Anal fissure | Painful defaecation, sentinel pile, linear tear visible |
| Perianal abscess/fistula | Pain, swelling, discharge |
| Condylomata acuminata | Wart-like perianal lesions |
| Solitary rectal ulcer syndrome | Straining, mucus, specific endoscopic/histological appearance |
7. Management
Step-up Approach
Conservative → Office Procedures → Surgery
A. Conservative Management (1st–2nd degree, mild)
- Dietary modification: High-fibre diet (25–35 g/day), adequate hydration
- Stool softeners / bulking agents (ispaghula husk, lactulose)
- Sitz baths (warm water, 10–15 min, 2–3x/day) — symptomatic relief
- Topical preparations (hydrocortisone + lidocaine): short-term symptom relief only; no evidence of cure
- Lifestyle: Avoid prolonged straining, regular exercise, normalise weight
B. Office (Outpatient / Non-operative) Procedures
| Procedure | Degree | Mechanism | Notes |
|---|
| Injection sclerotherapy | 1st, 2nd | 5% phenol in almond oil submucosal injection → fibrosis | Above dentate line; painless; max 3 quadrants per session |
| Rubber band ligation (RBL) | 2nd, 3rd | Band applied above dentate line → ischaemia → sloughing | Most effective outpatient procedure; avoid in anticoagulated patients |
| Infrared photocoagulation | 1st, 2nd | Heat coagulation → fibrosis | Less effective than RBL for bleeding |
| Bipolar diathermy / Electrocoagulation | 1st, 2nd | Thermal coagulation | Similar to infrared |
| Cryotherapy | Largely abandoned | Freezing → necrosis | High complication rate, poor wound healing |
Rubber band ligation is the gold-standard outpatient procedure — most cost-effective with lowest recurrence rates for 2nd–3rd degree haemorrhoids.
C. Surgical Management
Indications (Bailey & Love's, p. 1452)
- 3rd- and 4th-degree haemorrhoids
- 2nd-degree haemorrhoids failing non-operative treatments
- Mixed haemorrhoids with a well-defined external component
- Bleeding causing anaemia
- Strangulated haemorrhoids (urgent)
- Patient preference after counselling
Pre-operative Preparation
- Full history and examination, proctoscopy
- FBC, clotting, group & save
- Bowel preparation (phosphate enema on morning of surgery OR mechanical bowel prep)
- Consent (covering: bleeding, infection, anal stenosis, incontinence, recurrence, fistula)
- DVT prophylaxis (LMWH + TED stockings)
- Positioning: lithotomy (commonest) or jack-knife (prone)
- Anaesthesia: GA ± caudal/spinal block; local infiltration with adrenaline reduces bleeding
Operative Techniques
1. Milligan-Morgan Haemorrhoidectomy (Open) — Gold Standard
- Technique: Three haemorrhoidal pedicles excised with scissors/diathermy. The pedicle is transfixed and ligated at its base, then excised. Wounds are left open (heal by secondary intention).
- Crucial: Preserve skin bridges between excision sites (mucocutaneous bridges) to prevent anal stenosis.
- Advantages: Low recurrence, well-studied
- Disadvantages: Painful post-op (7–10 days), slow wound healing (4–6 weeks)
2. Ferguson Haemorrhoidectomy (Closed)
- Same excision as Milligan-Morgan, but wounds are closed with absorbable sutures
- More common in USA
- Less post-operative pain, faster healing but higher wound dehiscence risk
3. Stapled Haemorrhoidopexy (Procedure for Prolapse and Haemorrhoids — PPH)
- Technique: A circular stapling device (PPH-01 gun) is used to excise a doughnut of rectal mucosa/submucosa above the haemorrhoids. This:
- Interrupts arterial supply
- Repositions prolapsed cushions back into the anal canal (mucopexy)
- Advantages: Less post-operative pain, faster return to work, short op time
- Disadvantages:
- Cannot treat external haemorrhoids
- Higher recurrence and re-intervention rates long-term
- Risk of rare but serious complications: rectovaginal fistula, rectal perforation, staple line bleeding, pelvic sepsis
- NICE guidance: Acceptable alternative for 2nd–3rd degree; patients must be informed of higher long-term recurrence
4. Transanal Haemorrhoidal Dearterialisation (THD) / Haemorrhoidal Artery Ligation (HAL)
- Doppler-guided ligation of 6 terminal branches of the superior rectal artery
- Often combined with mucopexy (RAR — Recto-Anal Repair) to reduce prolapse
- Less painful than conventional haemorrhoidectomy
- Suitable for 2nd–4th degree
- Increasing evidence base; recurrence rates comparable to RBL in some studies
5. LigaSure / Harmonic Scalpel / Diathermy-Assisted Haemorrhoidectomy
- Modifications of Milligan-Morgan using vessel-sealing devices
- Reduced operative time, less blood loss, comparable pain and recurrence
6. Whitehead's Haemorrhoidectomy
- Circumferential excision of haemorrhoidal tissue
- Largely abandoned due to high complication rate: Whitehead's deformity (ectropion of rectal mucosa through anal canal → wet anus, mucus discharge, stenosis)
Post-operative Care
| Aspect | Detail |
|---|
| Analgesia | Regular paracetamol + NSAIDs (e.g. diclofenac); opioids if needed |
| Laxatives | Lactulose / Movicol from day 1 to prevent hard stools |
| Sitz baths | 2–3x daily from day 1 |
| Wound care | Keep clean and dry; gauze dressing changes |
| Diet | High-fibre from day 1 |
| Activity | Light activity encouraged; avoid heavy lifting 2–4 weeks |
| Follow-up | 4–6 weeks post-op; earlier if complications |
| Return to work | Typically 7–14 days (desk job); 2–4 weeks (manual) |
8. Complications
Early Complications
| Complication | Notes |
|---|
| Primary haemorrhage | Within 24 hrs; reactionary at 6 hrs; may require return to theatre |
| Urinary retention | Common (10–20%); exacerbated by spinal anaesthesia, pain, opioids |
| Pain | Significant with open haemorrhoidectomy; anticipated |
| Wound infection | Uncommon; perianal sepsis if severe |
| Faecal impaction | Analgesic-induced constipation; prevented with laxatives |
Late Complications
| Complication | Notes |
|---|
| Secondary haemorrhage | Days 7–10 (sloughing of ligated pedicle); may need re-admission |
| Anal stenosis | Caused by over-excision/insufficient skin bridges; prevent by preserving mucocutaneous bridges |
| Anal fissure | Secondary to stenosis or trauma |
| Faecal incontinence | Sphincter damage; risk with internal sphincter stretching (anal dilation now abandoned) |
| Recurrence | 5–10% at 5 years; higher with stapled procedure |
| Fistula-in-ano | Rare complication of overzealous dissection or sepsis |
9. Special Situations
Strangulated (Gangrenous) Haemorrhoids
- Emergency: Fourth-degree prolapse with oedema and vascular compromise
- Conservative: Ice packs, analgesia, reduction if possible — may allow semi-elective surgery in 6–8 weeks
- Emergency haemorrhoidectomy: Increased risk but acceptable; traditionally avoided due to oedema
- Thrombectomy for thrombosed external haemorrhoid within 72 hours gives best symptom relief
Thrombosed External Haemorrhoid
- <72 hours: Surgical excision under LA (not just incision — excise the whole haemorrhoid to prevent re-thrombosis) → rapid relief
- >72 hours: Conservative management (analgesia, sitz baths, laxatives) — spontaneous resolution over 2–4 weeks
Haemorrhoids in Pregnancy
- Conservative management throughout pregnancy
- Avoid surgery during pregnancy
- Most resolve post-partum
- If necessary, RBL can be performed in 2nd trimester
Portal Hypertension / Cirrhosis
- Anorectal varices (not true haemorrhoids) — can bleed massively
- Avoid conventional haemorrhoidectomy — catastrophic haemorrhage risk
- Treat the underlying portal hypertension (TIPSS, portosystemic shunt)
- Conservative measures only for true haemorrhoids in this context
Immunocompromised / HIV Patients
- Increased infection and poor wound healing risk
- Avoid surgery if possible; office procedures preferred
- If surgery necessary, cover with prophylactic antibiotics
10. Prognosis
- Conservative management: Effective for 1st–2nd degree in most patients; recurrence common if lifestyle not modified
- Rubber band ligation: 80–90% success for 2nd–3rd degree; may require repeat sessions
- Haemorrhoidectomy: Most definitive treatment; recurrence rates 2–5% at 5 years for open technique
- Stapled PPH: Higher symptomatic recurrence (up to 30% requiring re-intervention at 5 years in some trials — ETHOS trial, UK)
Summary Algorithm
Symptomatic Haemorrhoids
↓
Clinical Assessment + Proctoscopy (exclude malignancy)
↓
┌────────────────┬──────────────────┬─────────────────┐
1st Degree 2nd Degree 3rd Degree 4th Degree
↓ ↓ ↓ ↓
Conservative Conservative Conservative Surgery
+ Injection → RBL / Injection → RBL (try first) → Haemorrhoidectomy
Sclerotherapy → Surgery if fails → Surgery if fails (Milligan-Morgan
/ THD / Stapled)
References:
- Bailey & Love's Short Practice of Surgery, 28th Edition, p. 1452
- NICE Guideline IPG473 — Stapled haemorrhoidopexy
- ACPGBI (Association of Coloproctology of Great Britain and Ireland) — Haemorrhoids guidelines
- Goligher JC — Surgery of the Anus, Rectum and Colon (grading system)
- Thomson WH (1975) — The nature of haemorrhoids (sliding anal lining theory)