I now have all the data I need. Let me synthesize a comprehensive diagnostic report from the 23-page VNG.
VNG Diagnostic Report — Nishi Kathuria
Patient ID: CCDA00361 | Date: 08 May 2026 | Age: 61 years | Gender: Female
Facility: Priority Hearing Care Pvt. Ltd.
I. TEST-BY-TEST DATA SUMMARY
A. Saccades
| Parameter | 0.3 Hz Horizontal | 0.45 Hz Horizontal | 0.3 Hz Vertical | 0.45 Hz Vertical |
|---|
| Velocity (R / L) | 767 / 842 °/s | 671 / 544 °/s | 584 / 554 °/s | 671 / 590 °/s |
| Precision (R / L) | 78 / 81 | 64 / 73 | 90 / 88 | 94 / 87 |
| Latency (R / L) | 296 / 298 ms | 230 / 225 ms | 305 / 297 ms | 236 / 235 ms |
Interpretation: Saccade velocities, latencies, and precision are within normal limits bilaterally for both horizontal and vertical planes. No hypometria, hypermetria, or slowed saccades are seen. Normal saccade function.
B. Smooth Pursuit
| Test | Rightward Gain (R/L eye) | Leftward/Downward Gain (R/L eye) |
|---|
| 0.2 Hz Horizontal | 0.34 / 0.29 | 0.28 / 0.31 |
| 0.4 Hz Horizontal | 0.25 / 0.24 | 0.21 / 0.21 |
| 0.2 Hz Vertical | Upward: 0.38 / 0.38 | Downward: 0.28 / 0.27 |
| 0.4 Hz Vertical | Upward: 0.08 / 0.09 | Downward: 0.13 / 0.14 |
Interpretation: At 0.2 Hz, horizontal pursuit gain is reduced (normal ≥ 0.7–0.8 for a 61-year-old). At 0.4 Hz, horizontal pursuit gain is markedly diminished (0.21–0.25). Vertical pursuit at 0.4 Hz is severely degraded (0.08–0.14). This bilateral symmetric reduction in pursuit gain is consistent with diffuse smooth pursuit impairment — a pattern seen with central (cerebellar/brainstem) dysfunction or age-related central changes, though it can also reflect inattention or poor cooperation. The symmetry argues against a unilateral peripheral lesion.
C. Optokinetic Test (OKN)
| Direction | Gain (R / L eye) | Fast Phase Direction |
|---|
| Left-to-Right 10° | 1.04 / 0.98 | 22.91° (R eye) |
| Right-to-Left 10° | 0.96 / 1.11 | 161.03° (L eye) |
| Top-to-Bottom 10° | 1.05 / 1.01 | — (absent) |
| Bottom-to-Top 10° | 0.90 / 0.93 | 305.36° (R eye) |
Interpretation: Optokinetic gains are symmetric and essentially normal (close to 1.0) in all four directions. No OKN asymmetry. This finding argues against a significant unilateral central hemisphere lesion.
D. Spontaneous Nystagmus
| Condition | Horizontal SPV | Vertical SPV | Fast Phase | Frequency |
|---|
| In Light | Absent | Absent | — | — |
| In Dark | L eye: 2.25 °/s horizontal | −5.13 / −4.87 °/s vertical | 67.53° | 0.68 / 1.42 Hz |
Interpretation:
- No spontaneous nystagmus in light (normal).
- Spontaneous nystagmus in darkness: A low-amplitude, predominantly downward-oblique nystagmus (fast phase at ~67–68°, predominantly upward-vertical component). The horizontal component is minimal (2.25 °/s in the left eye only). The dominant vertical slow-phase velocity is −5 °/s bilaterally — present only in darkness (disappears with visual fixation).
This pattern — downbeat-predominant nystagmus suppressed by fixation — is a significant finding. Pure downbeat nystagmus (DBN) is classically associated with lesions at the cervicomedullary junction (foramen magnum region, cervicomedullary junction), cerebellar flocculus/nodulus, or can be seen with certain metabolic conditions (vitamin B12 deficiency, medications). Fixation suppression indicates some central mechanism is in play.
E. Head-Shake Nystagmus (High-Frequency)
| Parameter | Horizontal | Vertical |
|---|
| Horizontal SPV | Absent | — |
| Vertical SPV | −4.88 / −5.51 °/s | |
| Frequency | 0.75 / 0.93 Hz | |
Interpretation: No post-head-shake horizontal nystagmus — argues against a significant unilateral peripheral vestibular lesion (asymmetric peripheral loss characteristically produces horizontal head-shake nystagmus). A downward post-head-shake vertical nystagmus persists, further reinforcing the downbeat/central pattern.
F. Hyperventilation-Induced Nystagmus
| Parameter | R Eye | L Eye |
|---|
| H. SPV | +1.17 °/s | −1.60 °/s |
| V. SPV | −4.99 °/s | −4.04 °/s |
| Fast Phase Direction | 111.31° | 120.37° |
| Frequency | 1.52 Hz | 1.53 Hz |
Interpretation: Hyperventilation induces a mixed oblique downward-beating nystagmus (fast phase ~111–120° = oblique upward-rightward fast phase, meaning downward slow phase). Hyperventilation-induced nystagmus can indicate demyelinating lesions (MS), vestibular schwannoma, or central pathway abnormalities. The persistence of this downbeat pattern under hyperventilation is clinically meaningful.
G. Gaze Tests
| Position | With Fixation | Without Fixation |
|---|
| Center | Normal (no nystagmus) | Downbeat nystagmus: V SPV −6.00/−5.56 °/s; FPD 57.90° |
| Left | Normal | H SPV +4.62/+4.86 °/s; V SPV −4.23/−4.38 °/s; FPD 29–55° |
| Right | Normal | V SPV −5.48/−5.50 °/s only (no H component) |
| Up | Normal | V SPV −4.70/−4.51 °/s; FPD 43.52° |
| Down | Normal | H SPV +5.98/−0.82 °/s; V SPV −5.82/−6.71 °/s; FPD 52–82° |
Key observations:
- All gaze positions with fixation: normal — no gaze-evoked nystagmus.
- Without fixation (eyes open in dark): Nystagmus is revealed in all gaze positions with a predominantly downward slow-phase velocity (fast phase upward-oblique, ~50–140°). The nystagmus is consistently suppressed by visual fixation, indicating good central fixation suppression mechanism is partly intact.
- Horizontal components emerge in left and down gaze without fixation, suggesting a slightly oblique (downbeat + horizontal) vector rather than pure downbeat. This could represent a down-beating + torsional component typical of posterior canal/floccular pathology.
Interpretation: Persistent downbeat nystagmus in darkness across all gaze positions, suppressed by fixation. This is a central finding.
H. Positional Tests — Dix-Hallpike (DH)
DH Right
| Position | H SPV (R/L) | V SPV (R/L) | Fast Phase Direction | Frequency |
|---|
| Sit Head Right | −5.36/−8.70 °/s | −6.16/−6.32 °/s | 138.86°/132.29° | 1.34/1.58 Hz |
| Supine Head Ext + Right | —/−1.77 °/s | −6.55/−9.87 °/s | —/85.97° | 0.65/1.94 Hz |
| Sit Head Right (recovery) | −4.03/−5.75 °/s | −8.08/−7.71 °/s | 110.70°/114.62° | 1.65/1.75 Hz |
Fast phase direction ~110–139° (oblique upward-leftward/torsional fast phase) during right Dix-Hallpike supine — this corresponds to upbeat-torsional fast phases, which is the classic nystagmus of right posterior canal BPPV.
DH Left
| Position | H SPV (R/L) | V SPV (R/L) | Fast Phase Direction | Frequency |
|---|
| Sit Head Left | +6.48/+5.57 °/s | −4.17/−3.12 °/s | 32.29°/26.01° | 1.37/1.21 Hz |
| Supine Head Ext + Left | −16.33/−19.57 °/s | −47.77/−33.85 °/s | 110.03°/121.34° | 2.53/2.42 Hz |
| Sit Head Left (recovery) | +8.74/+8.29 °/s | −19.42/−8.20 °/s | 46.34°/32.08° | 1.63/1.40 Hz |
Critical finding: The Supine Head Extended + Left position provokes an extremely vigorous nystagmus — vertical slow-phase velocity −47.77/−33.85 °/s (very high amplitude), frequency 2.53/2.42 Hz, fast phase 110–121°. This is the highest-intensity positional nystagmus in the entire study. This magnitude of response (SPV > 30 °/s) during the left Dix-Hallpike is highly significant for left posterior canal BPPV or left canalith involvement — and the sheer velocity raises concern for a persistent (non-fatiguing) component.
I. Yacovino Maneuver (Central Positional Test for Anterior Canal / Cupulolithiasis)
| Position | H SPV (R/L) | V SPV (R/L) | Fast Phase Direction | Frequency |
|---|
| Supine Begin | — | −8.42/−7.83 °/s | — | 0.70/0.70 Hz |
| Supine Head Ext 90° | —/+5.01 °/s | −17.26/−20.82 °/s | —/66.21° | 1.08/1.56 Hz |
| Supine Head Flex 45° | −17.27/−21.85 °/s | −30.45/−26.55 °/s | 120.26°/129.31° | 2.31/2.33 Hz |
| Supine End | —/−12.09 °/s | −29.69/−17.88 °/s | —/129.83° | 0.92/1.99 Hz |
Critical finding: The Yacovino maneuver is specifically designed to test for anterior canal BPPV or central positional vertigo (particularly nodular/uvular lesions). Vigorous nystagmus is present throughout all positions of this maneuver — vertical SPVs of 17–30 °/s, with fast phase directions ~66–130°. The nystagmus is present even at Supine Begin (baseline supine) — meaning the patient has baseline positional nystagmus in supine position without requiring further provocation. This is very atypical for classic peripheral BPPV and strongly suggests a persistent positional downbeat nystagmus, which is a hallmark of central positional vertigo (anterior canal syndrome, floccular/nodular pathology).
J. McClure-Pagnini Test (Horizontal Canal BPPV)
| Position | H SPV (R/L) | V SPV (R/L) | Fast Phase Direction | Frequency |
|---|
| Sit to Supine | —/— | —/−12.42 °/s | — | —/0.76 Hz |
| Right Lateral | —/−7.51 °/s | −7.02/−12.04 °/s | —/120.79° | 1.08/2.02 Hz |
| Supine Head Neutral (1st) | −13.85/−19.72 °/s | −22.34/−17.52 °/s | 124.17°/137.64° | 2.11/2.09 Hz |
| Left Lateral | −30.86/−35.95 °/s | −43.80/−33.39 °/s | 126.09°/136.57° | 2.55/2.46 Hz |
| Supine Head Neutral (2nd) | −20.61/−20.80 °/s | −30.49/−20.44 °/s | 123.20°/138.92° | 2.00/2.13 Hz |
Critical findings:
- Nystagmus is present in all positions of the roll test, including the neutral supine head position (which should be absent or minimal in peripheral HC-BPPV).
- Left lateral roll produces the most intense response: H SPV −30–35 °/s, V SPV −43 °/s, frequency 2.55 Hz — extremely vigorous.
- The fast phase directions are consistently ~120–140° across all positions (oblique upward-left/torsional fast phases) — this is a non-direction-changing pattern relative to head position, which is atypical for horizontal canal BPPV (which should produce direction-changing geotropic or direction-fixed apogeotropic nystagmus that reverses with head roll to the opposite side).
- The persistence in neutral supine and the consistent fast phase direction regardless of roll direction is more consistent with central persistent positional nystagmus.
K. Subjective Visual Vertical (SVV)
| Condition | Deviation | Direction |
|---|
| Clockwise rotation | −1° (Left) | |
| Anti-clockwise rotation | −6° (Left) | |
| Blank background | −1° (Left) | |
Interpretation: SVV deviation of −1° to −6° to the left. Normal range is ±2°. The −6° deviation during the anticlockwise trial is abnormal and suggests a left-sided otolithic (utricular) dysfunction or mild tilt of the subjective vertical, consistent with a left-sided vestibular imbalance at the utricular level. The −1° readings are borderline.
II. INTEGRATED DIAGNOSTIC INTERPRETATION
Pattern Recognition
Pulling all findings together, the dominant pattern across this VNG is:
-
Persistent downbeat-predominant nystagmus — present in darkness, without fixation, in all gaze positions, in supine, and provoked in all positional maneuvers. Suppressed (but not abolished) by fixation.
-
Positional nystagmus present in ALL positions of ALL maneuvers — including positions that should be null/resting (supine neutral, sitting upright) — indicating the nystagmus is gravity-dependent and persistent, not paroxysmal.
-
Non-fatiguing, non-fatigable pattern — BPPV characteristically produces fatigable, short-lived paroxysmal nystagmus (<1 min). Here, nystagmus is present across extended recordings.
-
Extremely high SPV during left Dix-Hallpike supine (V SPV up to −47 °/s) and left lateral roll (H SPV −35 °/s, V SPV −43 °/s) — amplitudes this high in a 61-year-old woman are unusual for uncomplicated peripheral BPPV.
-
Smooth pursuit: diffusely impaired bilaterally — central pattern.
-
Saccades: normal — brainstem saccadic generator intact.
-
OKN: normal and symmetric — no hemispheric lesion.
-
Head-shake nystagmus: vertical (downbeat), no horizontal — no asymmetric peripheral loss.
-
SVV deviated left — left utricular involvement.
-
Hyperventilation-induced nystagmus (downbeat) — raises concern for demyelinating or compressive posterior fossa pathology.
III. DIAGNOSIS
Primary Diagnosis:
Central Positional Vertigo — Persistent Downbeat Positional Nystagmus (PDBPN)
Most consistent with dysfunction of the cerebellar flocculus/nodulus or anterior canal/posterior fossa pathology, producing gravity-dependent persistent downbeat nystagmus that is not position-specific, is present in supine and all provocative positions, is not fatigable, and is accompanied by diffuse smooth pursuit impairment.
Secondary / Co-existing Finding:
Left Posterior Canal BPPV (Probable)
The left Dix-Hallpike provoked the highest-amplitude positional nystagmus in the study. While the background persistent downbeat nystagmus complicates interpretation, the directionality and peak amplitude during left DH supine (fast phase 110–121°, upbeat-torsional) is consistent with a concurrent left posterior semicircular canal canalithiasis component, superimposed on the central baseline nystagmus.
Supporting Diagnosis:
Left Utricular Dysfunction (Mild)
Based on SVV deviation of up to −6° leftward on anti-clockwise trial, indicating left utricular/saccular otolithic imbalance.
IV. DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSES TO EXCLUDE
| Condition | For | Against |
|---|
| Cerebellar/floccular lesion (stroke, MS, tumor) | Persistent DBN, impaired smooth pursuit, hyperventilation-induced nystagmus, non-fatigable positional nystagmus | Normal saccades, normal OKN |
| Arnold-Chiari malformation | Persistent DBN, present in all positions, worsened in supine | Need MRI to confirm |
| Posterior fossa mass/MS plaque | DBN + hyperventilation nystagmus | No clinical data provided; need imaging |
| Medication-induced DBN | Age 61, common | History unknown (not provided) |
| Vitamin B12 / Magnesium deficiency | Can cause cerebellar DBN | Lab data needed |
| Peripheral BPPV alone | High-amplitude positional response | Nystagmus in all positions including neutral, persistent, non-fatigable, downbeat component |
V. CRITICAL RECOMMENDATIONS
-
MRI Brain with contrast (including high-resolution posterior fossa protocol, CISS/FIESTA sequences for IAC): To exclude cerebellar/brainstem lesion, Arnold-Chiari malformation, MS plaques, or posterior fossa tumor. This is the highest priority investigation given the persistent downbeat nystagmus pattern.
-
Neurology / Neuro-otology referral: Persistent downbeat nystagmus with smooth pursuit impairment requires formal neurological evaluation.
-
Left Epley Maneuver: If the co-existing left posterior canal BPPV component is confirmed clinically (onset latency, fatigability on repeat DH), a left Epley canalith repositioning maneuver can be attempted. However, clinician should be aware the baseline downbeat nystagmus will complicate assessment of success.
-
Medication review: Check for aminoglycosides, anticonvulsants (phenytoin, carbamazepine), lithium, alcohol, or benzodiazepines — all known causes of cerebellar downbeat nystagmus.
-
Serum B12, folate, magnesium, thiamine: Metabolic screen for reversible causes of cerebellar nystagmus.
-
4-Aminopyridine (4-AP) consideration: Evidence supports 4-AP (fampridine) as a pharmacotherapy for downbeat nystagmus of cerebellar origin — neurologist should assess.
VI. REPORT SUMMARY TABLE
| Domain | Result | Interpretation |
|---|
| Saccades (H + V) | Normal | Brainstem saccadic generator intact |
| Smooth Pursuit (H + V) | Bilaterally reduced (gain 0.08–0.34) | Central/cerebellar impairment |
| OKN | Normal, symmetric | No hemispheric lesion |
| Spontaneous Nystagmus in Light | Absent | Normal |
| Spontaneous Nystagmus in Dark | Downbeat + oblique, SPV ~5 °/s | Central downbeat nystagmus |
| Head-Shake Nystagmus | Vertical (downbeat), no horizontal | Central pattern; no peripheral asymmetry |
| Hyperventilation Nystagmus | Downbeat-oblique | Posterior fossa / demyelinating concern |
| Gaze Tests (fixation) | Normal in all positions | No gaze-evoked nystagmus |
| Gaze Tests (no fixation) | Downbeat across all positions | Persistent central downbeat nystagmus |
| Dix-Hallpike Right | Positive (moderate, oblique-upbeat) | Possible right posterior canal BPPV |
| Dix-Hallpike Left | Strongly positive (V SPV up to −47 °/s) | Left posterior canal BPPV + central |
| Yacovino Maneuver | Positive in ALL positions including baseline | Persistent positional; central etiology |
| McClure-Pagnini Roll Test | Positive ALL positions, non-direction-changing | Not consistent with peripheral HC-BPPV; central |
| SVV | −1° to −6° Left deviation | Left utricular dysfunction |
Overall Impression:
This VNG demonstrates a central vestibular syndrome characterised by persistent downbeat positional nystagmus across all maneuvers, diffuse smooth pursuit impairment, hyperventilation-induced downbeat nystagmus, and abnormal SVV leftward. A superimposed left posterior canal BPPV component is probable given the markedly elevated provoked nystagmus on left Dix-Hallpike. The pattern is most consistent with cerebellar (floccular-nodular) or posterior fossa pathology. MRI brain with posterior fossa protocol is urgently recommended before vestibular rehabilitation is initiated.
Report interpreted based on raw VNG data. Clinical correlation and physician review required. Final diagnosis rests with the treating clinician.
References: Cummings Otolaryngology Head & Neck Surgery; Bradley and Daroff's Neurology in Clinical Practice.