I now have all the content needed for a complete 5-mark answer. Let me compose it as a professor checking an answer sheet.
Water Purification on a Small Scale
Park's Textbook of Preventive & Social Medicine
(Model Answer - 5 Marks)
Small-scale (household/individual) water purification uses three principal methods, which may be applied singly or in combination.
(a) BOILING
Water must be brought to a "rolling boil" for 10-20 minutes. This kills all bacteria, spores, cysts, and ova, yielding sterile water. It also removes temporary hardness by driving off CO2 and precipitating calcium carbonate.
Limitation: Offers no residual protection against subsequent contamination. Water should be boiled and stored in the same container to minimise re-contamination.
(b) CHEMICAL DISINFECTION
Several agents are used:
| Agent | Key Details |
|---|
| Bleaching powder (CaOCl2) | Contains ~33% available chlorine; unstable on exposure to air/light/moisture. Target: free residual chlorine of 0.5 mg/L after 1 hour contact. |
| Chlorine solution | 4 kg bleaching powder (25% available Cl) + 20 L water = 5% chlorine solution. |
| High Test Hypochlorite (HTH/Perchloron) | Contains 60-70% available chlorine; more stable than bleaching powder. |
| Chlorine tablets (Halazone) | 0.5 g tablet disinfects 20 litres; convenient but costly. |
| Iodine | 2 drops of 2% ethanol solution per litre of clear water; contact time 20-30 minutes; useful for emergency disinfection. |
| KMnO4 | No longer recommended - not reliable against most organisms; alters colour, smell, and taste. |
The principle in all chlorination methods: achieve a free residual chlorine of 0.5 mg/litre at the end of 1 hour contact.
(c) CERAMIC FILTRATION
Water is passed through candle filters:
- Pasteur-Chamberland filter - porcelain candle
- Berkefeld filter - kieselguhr (infusorial earth) candle
- Katadyn filter - silver-coated surface; silver ions kill bacteria by oligodynamic action
Limitation: Remove bacteria but not filter-passing viruses. Candles clog with impurities and must be scrubbed weekly and boiled regularly. Not widely suitable under Indian field conditions.
(d) ULTRAVIOLET (UV) IRRADIATION
Water (up to 120 mm thick) is exposed to quartz mercury vapour arc lamps at 254 nm wavelength. Effective against bacteria, viruses, fungi, algae, protozoa, and cysts.
Advantages: Short exposure time, no foreign matter introduced, no taste/odour change, no harm from overexposure.
Disadvantages: No residual effect, no simple field test to assess efficacy, expensive apparatus. Water must be turbidity-free.
(e) MULTI-STAGE REVERSE OSMOSIS (RO)
Reduces total dissolved solids (TDS), hardness, heavy metals, and microorganisms (bacteria, viruses, protozoa, cysts), making water both chemically and microbiologically potable.
Stages typically include:
- Clarity cartridge - removes suspended particles (dust, mud, sand)
- Pre-carbon filter
- RO membrane
- Post-carbon filter
Examiner's Marking Scheme (5 marks)
| Component | Marks |
|---|
| Boiling - mechanism, duration, limitation | 1 |
| Chemical disinfection - at least 3 agents with details | 1.5 |
| Ceramic filtration - types, oligodynamic action, limitations | 1 |
| UV irradiation - wavelength, advantages, disadvantages | 0.5 |
| Reverse osmosis - principle and stages | 0.5 (bonus/extra credit) |
| Total | 5 |
Professor's Note: A complete 5-mark answer must cover boiling, at least 3 chemical agents with the 0.5 mg/L residual chlorine principle, and at least one filtration method with the oligodynamic action concept for Katadyn filter. UV and RO earn extra marks. Candidates who only list methods without mechanistic details lose 1-2 marks.
Source: Park's Textbook of Preventive and Social Medicine, Chapter on Water Supply