I now have comprehensive content covering all aspects. Let me compile the full answer.
Ingrown Toenail (Onychocryptosis / Unguis Incarnatus)
Definition
An ingrown toenail is a condition in which the lateral margin of the nail plate penetrates or impinges upon the adjacent periungual soft tissue (nail fold), causing pain, inflammation, and eventually infection and granulation tissue formation. It occurs predominantly on the great toe (hallux). - Roberts & Hedges' Clinical Procedures in Emergency Medicine
Pathology
Pathology of an ingrown toenail - Roberts & Hedges
The normal toenail grows distally with free space at the lateral nail margin. In onychocryptosis, the lateral edge of the nail acts as a foreign body, breaching the skin. Skin bacteria and fungi enter the wound, causing:
- Inflammation → erythema, oedema, hyperhidrosis, tenderness
- Bottlenecked poorly draining abscess
- Hypertrophic granulation tissue (ungualabia) that covers the nail fold, further inhibiting drainage
- Epithelium creeps over granulations → perpetuates the cycle
The condition is rare in people who do not wear shoes, indicating extrinsic pressure (shoe toe box) is central to the pathogenesis. - Campbell's Operative Orthopaedics 15e
Aetiology / Predisposing Factors
- Improper nail trimming - cutting the nail in a curve rather than straight across (most common cause)
- Ill-fitting footwear - lateral pressure from shoe toe box pushes the great toe against the second toe
- Nail deformity (incurvated/pincer nail)
- Rotational deformity of the toes
- Tight hosiery
- Trauma to the nail matrix
- Drugs: targeted cancer therapies, isotretinoin, lamivudine, indinavir (cause periungual granulation tissue mimicking onychocryptosis)
Proper vs improper nail trimming - Roberts & Hedges
Clinical Stages (Heifetz / Park Classification)
| Stage | Features | Treatment |
|---|
| Stage I (Inflammatory) | Mild erythema, swelling, tenderness of lateral nail fold; no abscess | Conservative: soaks, cotton elevation, nail splinting |
| Stage II (Abscess) | Stage I + bulging nail fold, drainage (initially serous → purulent), fetid odour; wearing shoes almost impossible | Usually operative; can try conservative initially |
| Stage III (Granulation/Chronic) | Hypertrophic granulation tissue covering lateral nail fold; epithelium creeping over granulations; recurrent acute episodes | Operative - surgery preferred |
Clinical Features
- Pain - often severe; the hallmark
- Erythema and swelling of the lateral nail fold
- Fluctuance when abscess forms
- Purulent discharge (fetid odour in stage II)
- Hypertrophic granulation tissue in stage III
- Pressure over nail margin worsens pain
- Walking becomes difficult; wearing shoes almost impossible in advanced cases
Key evaluation point: When the free edge of the lateral nail can easily be visualized as separate from the lateral nail fold, consider other diagnoses - gout, trauma, paronychia, cellulitis. - Roberts & Hedges
Complications to consider: In patients with diabetes, peripheral neuropathy, or circulatory dysfunction, recurrent or neglected cases may develop osteomyelitis of the distal phalanx.
Differential Diagnosis
- Acute paronychia (bacterial infection of nail fold)
- Gout (first MTP is typical site)
- Cellulitis/soft tissue infection
- Felon (pulp space abscess)
- Subungual haematoma/trauma
- Verruca (plantar wart at nail margin)
- Onychomycosis (thickened, dystrophic nail)
Management
Anaesthesia
For any invasive procedure: digital nerve block (lidocaine or mepivacaine without adrenaline), introduced 1 cm distal to the first web space, ensuring plantar digital nerves and dorsal sensory branches of the superficial peroneal nerve are anaesthetised. A tourniquet (Penrose drain or gloved finger) ensures a bloodless field. - Campbell's Operative Orthopaedics 15e
Stage I - Conservative (Non-operative)
- Warm soaks - 10-15 min, 3-5 times/day to soften nail
- Cotton/wool elevation technique - lift the lateral nail edge from its embedded position; insert non-absorbent cotton, dental floss, or acrylic mesh beneath the corner of the nail; patient repeats daily until nail grows out and can be trimmed properly. Success in 2-3 weeks if done consistently.
- Proper nail trimming - straight across (not curved), with corners protruding just distal to the hyponychium
- Gutter splint technique - a sterilised vinyl IV drip tube slit lengthwise, inserted along the nail groove and affixed with cyanoacrylate or adhesive tape, providing a channel for the nail to grow free of the fold. Recurrence rates 8-48%.
- Orthonyxia (nail bracing) - two hooks on the sides of the nail connected under tension by a super-elastic wire; straightens the nail within ~3 weeks. Better cosmesis and shorter recovery than surgery.
- "Band-aid" method - adhesive tape pulls the nail fold away from the nail to relieve pressure.
Stage II - Operative (or Conservative if very early)
If attempting non-operative management in early stage II: remove all pressure from the toe, soak 4-5 times/day, culture drainage, start broad-spectrum antibiotics; cotton elevation once swelling and drainage resolve.
When an abscess is present or conservative management fails: surgical I&D and nail spicule removal.
Removal of the nail spicule (simple/ED procedure)
- Digital nerve block + tourniquet
- Separate nail from nail bed with scissors/elevator advanced parallel to nail bed
- Split nail lengthwise toward the cuticle with iris scissors
- Grasp the cut portion with a haemostat and twist toward the remaining nail to avulse
- Inspect for and remove any residual nail spicule (a retained spicule is the most common cause of recurrence)
- Debride inflamed/granulation tissue
Stage III - Definitive Surgical Treatment
Operative approaches aim to either remove the offending nail (nail-centric view) or debulk/remove the hypertrophied nail fold (soft tissue-centric view).
1. Total Nail Plate Removal (Avulsion) - Technique 89.42
Rarely the definitive treatment alone (nail regrows and may re-offend). Indicated when abscess has circumducted both sides. Technique:
- Pass thin hemostat beneath nail in midline from hyponychium to lunula
- Repeat at each lateral margin
- Extract with distal pull; use sharp dissection at eponychium if adherent
- Post-op: non-adherent dressing, compression bandage, elevate foot 24 h, then warm soaks; no constricting footwear for 1 week
- Nail re-forms in 4-6 months (patient must be warned of turned-up pulp deformity with repeated avulsions)
2. Partial Nail Plate Removal - Technique 89.43
- Remove only the lateral quarter to third of the nail plate
- Preferred in adolescents when cosmetic preservation of the nail is important
- High recurrence rate without matrix ablation
- Risk of nail spicule formation and permanent nail deformity (patient/parents must be counselled)
3. Partial Nail Plate Removal + Chemical Matricectomy (Phenolisation) - Technique 89.44 (Most common definitive procedure)
The most widely used curative procedure. Combines partial nail avulsion with ablation of the germinal matrix using 80-89% phenol:
Steps:
- All personnel wear gloves (phenol is corrosive)
- Tourniquet at base of great toe
- Elevate the lateral quarter to fifth of nail edge longitudinally, from distal to proximal (including nail beneath the eponychium)
- Apply antibiotic gel around the nail fold to protect surrounding skin
- Insert a phenol-soaked cotton swab into the nail groove, extending beneath the eponychium, for 4 minutes without interruption
- Wash the area with isopropyl alcohol to neutralise residual phenol
Alternative ablative agents: Trichloroacetic acid, 10% sodium hydroxide, silver nitrate (especially in adolescents), CO₂ laser, electrocoagulation, cryotherapy (liquid nitrogen, 20-30 sec freeze - reserved for those not suitable for other approaches)
Outcomes of phenolisation:
- Phenol matricectomy: recurrence 18-32%
- Surgical (excisional) matricectomy: recurrence 7-8% but higher infection, pain, and cosmetic dissatisfaction
- One RCT found both equally effective at 1 year
- Trichloroacetic acid/NaOH: similar efficacy to phenol; faster healing with TCA
4. Nail Fold Excision (Winograd/Frost procedures)
For cases where the nail fold is the primary offender (hypertrophied soft tissue):
- Remove the overhanging lateral nail fold
- When healed, the nail edge resembles a thumbnail with an excellent functional result
- The nail itself is not altered
5. Total Nail Ablation (Zadik procedure)
- Complete permanent removal of the nail matrix
- Indicated for severe bilateral or chronic recurrent disease
- Gives a permanently nail-free toe
Post-operative Care and Patient Education
- Non-adherent dressing + compression bandage; elevate 24 hours
- Warm soaks from day 2
- No constricting footwear for 1 week
- Nail takes 4-6 months to fully regrow
- Prevention education:
- Trim nails straight across, not curved - goal is a squared nail with corners just protruding past the hyponychium
- Wear properly fitting, wide toe-box footwear
- Avoid nail-biting/picking
- In diabetics/neuropaths: regular podiatry review
Summary of Treatment by Stage
| Stage | First-line | Definitive if fails |
|---|
| Stage I | Cotton elevation, warm soaks, gutter splint, orthonyxia | Stage II/III approach |
| Stage II | Spicule removal ± antibiotics | Partial nail avulsion ± phenolisation |
| Stage III | Surgical | Partial/total nail avulsion + matricectomy |
Sources: Campbell's Operative Orthopaedics 15e (2026); Roberts & Hedges' Clinical Procedures in Emergency Medicine; Andrews' Diseases of the Skin; Dermatology 2-Vol Set 5e; Textbook of Family Medicine 9e