I now have sufficient material to compose a comprehensive answer. Let me synthesize it all.
Malformations of the Genitourinary System: Hypospadias & Epispadias
I. HYPOSPADIAS
Definition
Hypospadias is a congenital malformation in which the urethral meatus opens on the ventral (inferior) surface of the penis — anywhere from the glans to the perineum — rather than at the tip of the glans. It is often accompanied by chordee (ventral penile curvature) and a dorsally hooded prepuce.
Embryology
Normal urethral development depends on androgen-driven fusion of the urethral folds along the ventral midline (weeks 8–14 of gestation). Failure of complete fusion leads to hypospadias. The more proximal the arrest, the more severe the defect.
Incidence
- Approximately 1 in 200–300 male births (one of the most common congenital penile anomalies)
- Higher incidence in first-degree relatives
Classification
Classified by the location of the ectopic meatus:
| Type | Meatal Position |
|---|
| Distal (anterior) | Glanular, coronal, distal shaft (~70%) |
| Middle | Midshaft |
| Proximal (posterior) | Proximal shaft, penoscrotal, scrotal, perineal (~30%) |
Clinical Features
- Abnormal urinary stream (deflected downward/ventral)
- Chordee — ventral curvature of the penis (more common in proximal types)
- Dorsal hooded prepuce (incomplete foreskin ventrally)
- Difficulty with micturition in proximal types
- Psychosocial / sexual dysfunction if untreated
Associations
- Cryptorchidism (~10%)
- Inguinal hernia
- In severe cases: disorders of sex development (DSD) should be excluded
Management
(Bailey & Love's, p. 1561)
Surgical correction is the mainstay:
- Timing: Ideally before 18 months of age
- Distal hypospadias:
- Often repaired for cosmetic and functional reasons
- Technique of choice: Tubularised Incised Plate (TIP) urethroplasty (Snodgrass procedure)
- Proximal hypospadias with chordee: Two-stage repair
- Stage 1: Correct penile curvature (chordee release ± skin grafting)
- Stage 2: Urethral reconstruction (urethroplasty using preputial or buccal mucosa)
- Circumcision should be avoided prior to repair — preputial skin is valuable tissue for reconstruction
Complications of Surgery
- Urethrocutaneous fistula (most common)
- Meatal stenosis
- Urethral stricture
- Wound dehiscence
- Persistent/recurrent chordee
II. EPISPADIAS
Definition
Epispadias is a rare congenital dorsal penile defect in which the urethral meatus opens on the dorsal (superior) surface of the penis. The opening may lie anywhere from the glans to the penopubic junction (Bailey & Love's, p. 300).
A useful conceptual mnemonic: if hypospadias results from a ventral opening (scissors blade into the urethra, cutting ventrally), epispadias is the dorsal counterpart — cutting dorsally through the penis and pubis into the bladder.
Incidence
- Much rarer than hypospadias: ~1 in 117,000 males, ~1 in 484,000 females
Embryology
Results from failure of the cloacal membrane to be replaced by mesenchymal tissue during embryogenesis, leading to premature rupture of the cloacal/urogenital membrane.
Classification (Males)
| Type | Description |
|---|
| Glanular | Meatus on dorsal glans (mildest) |
| Penile | Meatus on dorsal shaft |
| Penopubic (complete) | Meatus at penopubic junction; sphincter usually incompetent → incontinence |
Epispadias–Exstrophy Complex
Epispadias exists on a spectrum with bladder exstrophy:
| Condition | Features |
|---|
| Isolated epispadias | Dorsal penile opening only; bladder intact |
| Bladder exstrophy | Bladder and bladder neck open on lower abdominal wall; epispadias always present |
| Cloacal (ileocaecal) exstrophy | Most severe variant: exomphalos + everted caecum/ileum separating two bladder halves + split penis |
Clinical Features
- Dorsal urethral opening on the penis
- Dorsal chordee (upward penile curvature)
- Urinary incontinence — common, especially in penopubic type (incompetent bladder neck)
- Widened pubic symphysis (diastasis) in exstrophy
- Fertility issues — retrograde ejaculation, epididymo-orchitis risk
In Females
- Short, wide urethra with cleft clitoris
- Incontinence is the predominant symptom
- Bifid clitoris
Management
Complex multistep surgical reconstruction, often in a staged approach:
- Penile/bladder neck reconstruction — restore continence
- Urethral reconstruction — tubularize the dorsal urethral plate
- Pelvic osteotomy — for bladder exstrophy (to close the pubic diastasis)
- Bladder augmentation / urinary diversion — in severe exstrophy
- Boys with epispadias and a functioning bladder neck may achieve continence with reconstructive surgery alone (Bailey & Love's, p. 300)
III. COMPARISON: Hypospadias vs. Epispadias
| Feature | Hypospadias | Epispadias |
|---|
| Meatal location | Ventral surface | Dorsal surface |
| Chordee direction | Ventral (downward) | Dorsal (upward) |
| Incidence | ~1:200–300 | ~1:117,000 |
| Incontinence | Rare | Common (penopubic type) |
| Associated anomaly | Cryptorchidism, hernia | Bladder exstrophy, diastasis pubis |
| Prepuce | Dorsal hood | Often absent/abnormal |
| Surgical timing | Before 18 months | Staged from neonatal period |
| Key repair | TIP urethroplasty | Bladder/urethra reconstruction ± osteotomy |
Sources: Bailey and Love's Short Practice of Surgery, 28th Edition (pp. 300, 1561)