This is exactly what I needed. Now I have a complete, textbook-confirmed answer. Here is the full breakdown:
The Case: Urosepsis (from E. coli or Klebsiella - a lactose-fermenting organism)
What the image shows
The case (Question A8) is:
A 65-year-old woman with a history of recurrent UTIs presents with fever, chills, and altered sensorium. Urine culture and blood cultures are positive for a lactose-fermenting organism.
Someone has written "Salmonella typhi" as the answer - and you are right to question it. That is the wrong diagnosis.
Why "Salmonella typhi" is incorrect
This is the key point from Jawetz, Melnick & Adelberg's Medical Microbiology:
Question 3 (same textbook, p. block3): "Blood cultures grow a non-lactose-fermenting Gram-negative bacillus" - this is what characterizes Salmonella Typhi.
Salmonella Typhi is a NON-lactose fermenter. The case explicitly states the organism IS a lactose fermenter. This alone rules out Salmonella completely.
Also, the classic typhoid fever presentation is very different:
- Travel history to endemic area
- Relative bradycardia
- Rose spots on trunk
- Step-ladder fever pattern
- NOT associated with recurrent UTIs
What the correct diagnosis is
Urosepsis - sepsis secondary to urinary tract infection, caused by a lactose-fermenting Gram-negative bacillus, most likely:
| Organism | Notes |
|---|
| Escherichia coli | Most common cause of urosepsis (~80% of UTI bacteremias); lactose fermenter; pink colonies on MacConkey agar |
| Klebsiella pneumoniae | Second most common; also a lactose fermenter; mucoid colonies |
The clinical features all fit urosepsis:
- Elderly woman (age 65 - host risk factor)
- Recurrent UTIs (predisposing condition - repeated seeding of bacteria)
- Fever + chills (systemic inflammatory response)
- Altered sensorium (sepsis-associated encephalopathy - hallmark of severe sepsis/septic shock in the elderly)
- Positive urine AND blood cultures (confirms hematogenous spread from urinary source = urosepsis)
- Lactose-fermenting organism = Enterobacteriaceae, pointing to E. coli or Klebsiella - the textbook answer
The annotated "EC" circled on the image
The circled annotation on the left likely stands for "E. coli" - which confirms the correct answer.
Summary
| Feature | Written (Wrong) | Correct |
|---|
| Organism | Salmonella typhi | E. coli (or Klebsiella) |
| Lactose fermentation | Non-fermenter | Fermenter |
| Source | Fecal-oral/enteric | Urinary tract |
| Diagnosis | Typhoid fever | Urosepsis |
The organism noted in the annotation as "Salmonella typhi" is a non-lactose fermenter and does not cause UTI-associated bacteremia in this pattern. The correct answer is urosepsis due to E. coli (most likely), confirmed by the circled "EC" on the page itself.
- Jawetz, Melnick & Adelberg's Medical Microbiology 28th Ed., block 3 (review Q2-3)
- Bailey and Love's Short Practice of Surgery, block 1 (lactose-fermenting Enterobacteriaceae)