I now have comprehensive content from multiple textbooks. Let me compile the full detailed answer.
Surgery for Uterovaginal (UV) Prolapse
Surgery is indicated when conservative management (pelvic floor physiotherapy, ring pessary, topical oestrogen) has failed or is not acceptable, when prolapse is symptomatic, or when the patient is fit and wishes definitive treatment. The surgical approach depends on the compartment(s) involved, the degree of prolapse, whether uterine preservation is desired, and the patient's fitness, age, and sexual activity.
Overview: Compartment-Based Approach
UV prolapse is addressed compartment by compartment, and often multiple repairs are done at one sitting:
| Compartment | Defect | Surgery |
|---|
| Anterior | Cystocele / urethrocele | Anterior colporrhaphy |
| Apical | Uterine descent / vault prolapse | Vaginal hysterectomy ± sacrospinous fixation; Manchester repair; sacrocolpopexy; uterosacral ligament suspension |
| Posterior | Rectocele / enterocele | Posterior colporrhaphy + perineorrhaphy; enterocele repair |
| Complete / elderly | Procidentia | Colpocleisis (Le Fort) |
1. Anterior Compartment - Anterior Colporrhaphy (Anterior Vaginal Wall Repair)
Indication: Cystocele, urethrocele
Principle: Plication of the pubocervical fascia beneath the bladder to reduce the anterior wall bulge.
Steps:
- Patient in lithotomy position; catheterise bladder.
- Inject dilute adrenaline solution under anterior vaginal wall to hydrodissect.
- Vertical midline incision on anterior vaginal wall from just below the urethral meatus to the cervix/vault.
- Dissect the vaginal epithelium laterally off the pubocervical fascia using sharp/blunt dissection.
- Identify the fascial edges and plicate them in the midline using interrupted or continuous absorbable sutures (2-0 Vicryl), reducing the bladder neck and bladder.
- Trim excess vaginal epithelium.
- Close vaginal skin with a continuous absorbable suture.
Complications: Haemorrhage, urinary fistula, voiding dysfunction, de novo stress urinary incontinence (unmasking of occult SUI), dyspareunia, recurrence (~30%).
Note on mesh: Mesh-augmented anterior repair had higher short-term anatomical success but carries significant risks (pain, erosion, dyspareunia) and is restricted in the UK. Current standard is native tissue repair.
2. Apical Compartment Procedures
A. Vaginal Hysterectomy (with Pelvic Floor Repair)
The most common definitive operation for uterine prolapse when fertility is not required.
Pre-operative: Bowel prep, catheter, thromboprophylaxis.
Steps:
- Lithotomy position. Cervix grasped with Vulsellum forceps.
- Circumferential incision around the cervix at the cervicovaginal junction (ring incision).
- Anterior dissection: Bladder pushed upward; anterior peritoneum of the pouch of vesicouterine peritoneum opened.
- Posterior dissection: Posterior vaginal wall opened; pouch of Douglas (posterior peritoneum) entered.
- Clamping of ligaments (in sequence):
- Uterosacral and cardinal ligaments (Mackenrodt ligaments) - clamped, cut, ligated bilaterally. These are the most important supports. The pedicles are later incorporated into the vault repair.
- Broad ligament / uterine vessels - clamped, cut, ligated.
- Cornual pedicles (round ligament, tube and ovarian ligament or infundibulopelvic ligament if oophorectomy required).
- Uterus delivered and removed.
- Vault closure and apical support: The vaginal vault is closed, incorporating the uterosacral-cardinal ligament pedicles into the angles of the vault closure to provide apical support. This is the McCall culdoplasty technique - placing sutures through the uterosacral ligaments and posterior vaginal wall to obliterate the pouch of Douglas and elevate the vault.
- Anterior and/or posterior colporrhaphy + perineorrhaphy performed as needed.
Complications: Haemorrhage (uterine vessels, vaginal plexus), bladder injury (most common, especially anteriorly), ureteric injury, rectal injury, vault haematoma, infection, subsequent vault prolapse.
B. Manchester (Fothergill) Repair - Uterus-Preserving
Indication: Uterine descent/cervical elongation when uterus preservation is desired, and family is complete (relative - fertility may still be possible but complications exist).
Principle: Amputation of the elongated cervix + plication of the cardinal ligaments (transverse cervical/Mackenrodt) in front of the remaining cervix to elevate it + anterior colporrhaphy.
Steps:
- Anterior vaginal wall opened, bladder dissected upward.
- Cardinal (transverse cervical) ligaments identified and divided on each side.
- Cervical amputation at the level of internal os. The Sturmdorf suture is used to re-cover the raw cervical stump with vaginal skin (reduces stenosis).
- The cut ends of the cardinal ligaments are sutured together anteriorly to the residual cervical stump - this is the Fothergill stitch - providing apical elevation.
- Anterior colporrhaphy and posterior repair done as required.
Specific complications: Cervical stenosis, infertility, miscarriage in subsequent pregnancy, dystocia, inability to assess cervix on smear.
C. Sacrospinous Ligament Fixation (SSLF)
Indication: Vaginal vault prolapse (post-hysterectomy) or uterine prolapse when uterus preservation is requested (uterosacral hysteropexy variant). One of the most commonly performed vaginal apical procedures.
Principle: The vaginal vault (or posterior cervix) is attached by non-absorbable sutures to the sacrospinous ligament (usually right-sided), suspending it to this strong fibromuscular structure.
Anatomy of sacrospinous ligament (SSL): Runs from the ischial spine to the lateral sacrum and coccyx. Closely related to the pudendal nerve and vessels (in Alcock's canal just medial), inferior gluteal vessels, sciatic nerve, and hypogastric plexus. Sutures must be placed 1.5-3 cm medial to the ischial spine to avoid these structures.
Steps:
- Midline posterior vaginal incision; enter rectovaginal space by blunt dissection, pushing rectum medially.
- Identify ischial spine; blunt dissection exposes the SSL.
- Breisky-Navratil or Heaney retractors used for exposure.
- Two non-absorbable sutures (e.g. PDS or Prolene) placed through the SSL approximately 1.5-2 fingerbreadths medial to the ischial spine - using a Capio suture device, Miyazaki hook, or Deschamps ligature carrier.
- Sutures brought through the vaginal vault and tied, pulling the vault to the ligament ("pulley sutures" - delayed tying until other repairs complete).
- Concomitant anterior and posterior colporrhaphy performed if needed.
Results: Apical success ~90-96%, but anterior wall failure (recurrence of cystocele) is the most common problem (~12-16%) due to the posterior and rightward deflection of the vaginal axis.
Complications: Buttock/perineal pain (most common - usually resolves within 3 months due to gluteal nerve/inferior gluteal vessel proximity), haemorrhage from pudendal vessels, sciatic nerve injury, rectal injury, dyspareunia, vaginal axis deflection posteriorly.
D. Uterosacral Ligament Suspension (High Uterosacral Colpopexy)
Indication: Vaginal vault prolapse or apical prolapse, vaginal or laparoscopic approach.
Principle: Vault sutured to remnants of the uterosacral ligaments bilaterally at the level of the ischial spine, restoring the normal horizontal vaginal axis (unlike SSLF which creates a posterior deflection).
Steps (vaginal approach):
- Vaginal vault opened; peritoneum of pouch of Douglas entered.
- Uterosacral ligaments identified on each side at the level of the ischial spine.
- Permanent or delayed-absorbable sutures (2-3 per side) placed through uterosacral ligaments.
- Sutures attached to the full thickness of the vaginal vault bilaterally.
- Culdoplasty (McCall) performed to close the cul-de-sac.
- Peritoneum closed; vault suspended.
Key risk: Ureteric kinking/injury (up to 11% ureteric obstruction rate); cystoscopy with indigo carmine dye is mandatory at the end of the procedure to confirm ureteric patency.
E. Sacrocolpopexy (Abdominal/Laparoscopic/Robotic)
The gold standard for vault prolapse, with best long-term anatomical results.
Indication: Vaginal vault prolapse (post-hysterectomy), Stage III-IV prolapse, failed prior vaginal repairs, young sexually active patients where durability is important.
Principle: A Y-shaped polypropylene mesh bridges the vaginal vault to the sacral promontory (S1/S2), providing durable apical suspension along the vaginal axis.
Steps (laparoscopic / robotic - same principle as open):
- Patient in Trendelenburg; bowel retracted.
- Retroperitoneal dissection to expose the sacral promontory (S1 level). Identify right ureter, middle sacral artery and vein.
- Dissect vesicovaginal space anteriorly (between bladder and vagina) and rectovaginal space posteriorly.
- Y-mesh: anterior arm sutured to anterior vaginal wall (2-3 cm below vault), posterior arm to posterior vaginal wall, trunk to the sacral promontory with permanent sutures (Prolene) or bone anchors.
- Peritoneum closed over the mesh (retroperitonealise) to prevent bowel adhesions.
- Concomitant Burch colposuspension or mid-urethral sling can be added for stress incontinence.
Results: Anatomical success ~95% at 5 years; superior to SSLF for anterior compartment support (avoids anterior wall recurrence). Long-term durability well documented.
Complications: Mesh erosion into vagina (~3-5%), mesh infection, haemorrhage from middle sacral vessels (life-threatening), L5 osteomyelitis (rare), bowel obstruction, ileus, ureteric injury, de novo SUI after vault elevation.
F. Sacrohysteropexy (Uterus-Preserving Abdominal Approach)
Same as sacrocolpopexy but the uterus is retained. Mesh attached to the posterior cervix and carried up to the sacral promontory. Laparoscopic approach (laparoscopic sacrohysteropexy) is increasingly performed with good results and avoids the complications of hysterectomy.
3. Posterior Compartment - Posterior Colporrhaphy + Perineorrhaphy
Indication: Rectocele, enterocele, deficient perineum.
Steps:
- Allis forceps applied to posterior fourchette; triangular skin incision on perineum.
- Midline vertical incision up the posterior vaginal wall to the vaginal apex.
- Vaginal skin dissected laterally off the rectovaginal fascia.
- Enterocele sac (if present) identified, opened, hernial sac contents reduced, neck ligated with a purse-string suture, sac excised.
- Levator ani muscles approximated in the midline with interrupted absorbable sutures (levatorplasty) - note: over-aggressive levatorplasty causes dyspareunia.
- Pubocervical / rectovaginal fascia plicated in the midline over the rectum.
- Excess vaginal skin trimmed.
- Perineal body reconstructed (perineorrhaphy) using interrupted sutures to rebuild the perineal body.
- Vaginal skin and perineal skin closed.
Complications: Haemorrhage, rectal injury, dyspareunia (most significant long-term complaint, especially if over-zealous levatorplasty), recurrence.
4. Obliterative Procedures - Colpocleisis (Le Fort's Procedure)
Indication: Elderly or medically unfit women with complete prolapse (procidentia) who no longer wish to have sexual intercourse. Offers the highest success rates with the lowest surgical morbidity.
Principle: The anterior and posterior vaginal walls are sutured together, obliterating the vaginal canal. The uterus (if present) remains inside; tunnels are left laterally for uterine drainage.
Steps (Le Fort partial colpocleisis):
- Rectangular strips of vaginal epithelium removed from anterior and posterior vaginal walls.
- Denuded anterior and posterior surfaces approximated with interrupted absorbable sutures, effectively closing off the vaginal canal while leaving lateral drainage channels for any cervical/uterine discharge.
- Perineorrhaphy performed.
Results: Recurrence rate <5%; very high patient satisfaction. Cannot be reversed. Requires exclusion of cervical/endometrial malignancy first.
Contraindication: Any woman who may wish to have penetrative intercourse in the future.
5. Mesh Considerations
Mesh augmentation (transvaginal mesh kits) was widely used in the 2000s but has been restricted in the UK, Australia, and many other countries due to significant adverse events:
- Chronic pelvic/vaginal/buttock pain
- Mesh erosion into vagina or bladder/rectum
- Dyspareunia
- Recurrent UTI and voiding dysfunction
Current guidelines require MDT assessment, detailed counselling, and specialist centre referral before any mesh-based prolapse repair. Sacrocolpopexy (abdominal mesh) remains acceptable under these conditions, while transvaginal mesh kits are largely abandoned.
6. Choice of Procedure - Summary
| Patient Profile | Preferred Operation |
|---|
| Uterine prolapse, family complete | Vaginal hysterectomy + McCall culdoplasty + anterior/posterior repair |
| Uterine prolapse, wishes uterus retained | Manchester repair OR laparoscopic sacrohysteropexy |
| Vault prolapse (post-hysterectomy), vaginal approach | SSLF or uterosacral ligament suspension |
| Vault prolapse, young/active patient | Laparoscopic sacrocolpopexy |
| Elderly, medically unfit, procidentia | Colpocleisis (Le Fort) |
| Isolated cystocele | Anterior colporrhaphy |
| Isolated rectocele | Posterior colporrhaphy + perineorrhaphy |
Recurrence rate across all prolapse surgeries is approximately 30% lifetime, increasing with subsequent procedures. - Bailey & Love's Short Practice of Surgery, 28th Ed., p. 1612; Campbell-Walsh-Wein Urology, pp. 3693-3696