Discoid Meniscus
Definition & Anatomy
A discoid meniscus is a congenital anatomical variant in which the meniscus — almost exclusively the lateral meniscus — is abnormally large, thick, and disc-shaped rather than the normal crescent (semilunar) form. It covers most or all of the lateral tibial plateau instead of just the periphery.
Epidemiology
- Incidence: ~3–5% in Western populations; higher in Asian populations (up to 15%)
- Predominantly affects the lateral meniscus; discoid medial meniscus is rare
- Often bilateral (~20% of cases)
Classification (Watanabe)
| Type | Description |
|---|
| Type I — Complete | Disc covers entire tibial plateau; most common type |
| Type II — Incomplete | Partial coverage of tibial plateau |
| Type III — Wrisberg variant | Normal shape but lacks normal posterior meniscotibial (coronary) ligament attachment; highly unstable and prone to subluxation |
Pathophysiology
The abnormal shape leads to:
- Altered biomechanics and stress distribution across the knee
- Increased susceptibility to tears (horizontal cleavage tears most common)
- The Wrisberg variant lacks posterior ligamentous attachment, causing the meniscus to snap or displace during motion
Clinical Presentation
| Feature | Detail |
|---|
| Age | Children and adolescents most commonly; may present in adulthood |
| Classic sign | Painful clunk (audible/palpable snap) during knee extension — pathognomonic in children |
| Symptoms | Lateral knee pain, swelling, limited ROM, locking, giving way |
| Wrisberg variant | Dramatic snapping syndrome without a tear |
Bailey and Love's (p. 644) describes the hallmark as "a painful clunk on knee extension."
Diagnosis
X-ray findings (indirect signs):
- Widened lateral joint space
- Cupping/hypoplasia of lateral tibial plateau
- Elevated lateral fibular head
MRI (gold standard):
- Sagittal view: ≥3 consecutive 5 mm slices showing continuity of anterior and posterior horns (the "bow-tie sign")
- Coronal view: Abnormally wide transverse diameter of lateral meniscus extending beyond the tibial rim
- Identifies associated tears (horizontal cleavage tears most common)
Panels A–B: Sagittal and coronal MRI showing continuous horns and widened lateral meniscus. Panel C: Preoperative arthroscopic view of incomplete discoid meniscus. Panel D: Post-saucerization with plasma knife. Panel E: Return to sports.
Arthroscopy: Definitive visualization; used therapeutically.
Management
Asymptomatic discoid meniscus — no intervention required; observation only.
Symptomatic (pain, mechanical symptoms, tear):
Arthroscopic saucerization (meniscoplasty) — primary treatment
- Resection and remodeling of the meniscus to a normal semilunar shape (~4 mm peripheral rim retained)
- Preferred over total meniscectomy to preserve meniscal function
Additional procedures:
- If a tear is present: repair if possible, especially in the vascularized peripheral zone
- Wrisberg variant: peripheral stabilization (repair of posterior attachments) in addition to saucerization
Total meniscectomy — historical, now avoided due to high rates of subsequent lateral compartment osteoarthritis.
Complications
- Untreated: progressive lateral compartment OA, especially with total meniscectomy
- Post-saucerization: residual or recurrent tears, lateral compartment OA over time, stiffness
- Re-tear of the residual meniscus is the most common post-operative issue
Prognosis
Outcomes after arthroscopic saucerization are generally good, with most patients (including children) returning to full activity and sports. Early intervention before articular cartilage damage occurs improves long-term outcomes. Total meniscectomy is associated with a significantly higher rate of late-onset lateral compartment arthrosis.