Here is the Paediatric Surgery-focused deep dive into CDH/DDH — structured the way a surgical committee discussion would flow:
CDH / DDH — Paediatric Surgery Committee Discussion
1. The Surgical Objective (Core Principle)
"The objective is to obtain a stable, congruous reduction of the femoral head within the acetabulum while avoiding damage to the capital epiphysis (Avascular Necrosis), which causes stiffness and proximal femoral deformity."
— Bailey & Love's Surgery, 28th Ed., p. 638
Every surgical decision in DDH revolves around two competing risks:
- Under-treatment → persistent dislocation → early osteoarthritis
- Over-treatment / forceful reduction → AVN → femoral head destruction
2. Surgical Decision Framework by Age
The age of the child at diagnosis is the single most important factor guiding surgical strategy.
Age at Diagnosis
│
├── 0–6 months ──────────────► Pavlik Harness (Non-operative)
│
├── 6–18 months ─────────────► Closed Reduction + Spica Cast
│ (± Preliminary Traction)
│
├── 18 months – 4 years ─────► Open Reduction ± Femoral Osteotomy
│ ± Pelvic Osteotomy
│
└── >4 years ────────────────► Open Reduction + Combined Osteotomies
(Salvage procedures in adults)
3. Non-Operative Management (Surgical Awareness Required)
Pavlik Harness (0–6 months)
Image (a): Pavlik harness — "human position" with flexion ~100° and controlled abduction. Image (b): Lorenz/Daimler position — extreme abduction >90°, now largely abandoned due to high AVN risk.
| Parameter | Detail |
|---|
| Mechanism | Gravity + muscle activity spontaneously reduces and holds hip |
| Position | Hip flexion 100–110°, abduction 40–60° ("human position") |
| Duration | Full-time until stable, then part-time; total ~3–6 months |
| Success rate | ~85–95% for Graf IIc–IV in neonates |
| Failure criteria | No reduction within 3–4 weeks → discontinue (risk of Pavlik disease) |
Pavlik Disease — a specific complication where the harness holds the femoral head against the posterior acetabular wall, eroding it and making subsequent reduction more difficult. Requires prompt recognition and abandonment of the harness.
Contraindications to Pavlik:
- Age >6 months
- Teratologic dislocation (arthrogryposis, myelomeningocele)
- Failure of reduction after 3–4 weeks trial
4. Closed Reduction Under Anaesthesia (6–18 months)
Pre-operative: Skin or Skeletal Traction (1–3 weeks)
- Gradually stretches soft tissues (iliopsoas, adductors, capsule)
- Brings femoral head down to level of acetabulum
- Reduces the risk of AVN post-reduction
- Some centres have moved away from routine traction; still used selectively
The Procedure:
- General anaesthesia
- Arthrogram — contrast injected into hip joint; confirms position of femoral head, identifies obstacles (inverted labrum = "rose thorn" sign, hourglass capsule)
- Adductor tenotomy — if abduction <45°; performed percutaneously or open to widen safe zone
- Gentle reduction manoeuvre (Ortolani manoeuvre)
- Assess safe zone (Ramsey's zone) — arc between:
- Position where hip redislocates (lateral)
- Position where AVN risk begins (extreme abduction, medially)
- Safe zone must be ≥20–30° wide for closed reduction to be acceptable
- Apply hip spica cast in safe position (typically 45–60° abduction, 90–100° flexion, neutral rotation)
Post-operative:
- MRI or CT to confirm concentric reduction (X-ray unreliable in infants)
- Spica cast changed every 6–8 weeks under GA
- Total casting: 3–6 months
- Followed by Pavlik/abduction brace for further remodeling
5. Open Reduction (18 months and above)
Indicated when:
- Closed reduction fails or safe zone inadequate
- Age >18 months (soft tissue obstacles unlikely to resolve)
- Late-presenting cases
- Teratologic dislocations
Obstacles to Reduction (Surgical Anatomy)
Before open reduction, the surgeon must systematically address each obstacle:
| Obstacle | Location | Surgical Action |
|---|
| Hourglass capsule constriction | Capsule itself | Capsulotomy + capsulorrhaphy |
| Inverted/hypertrophied labrum (limbus) | Acetabular rim | Excised or repositioned |
| Pulvinar | Fibrofatty tissue filling acetabulum | Excised |
| Ligamentum teres | Inside joint | Divided if excessively elongated |
| Iliopsoas tendon | Crosses capsular neck | Lengthened/released |
| Tight adductors | Medial thigh | Adductor tenotomy |
| Shallow acetabulum | Bony deficiency | Pelvic osteotomy |
| Coxa valga + anteversion | Proximal femur | Femoral osteotomy |
Surgical Approaches
A. Medial Approach (Ludloff) — 6 to 24 months
- Between adductor longus and pectineus (or gracilis)
- Excellent access to medial obstacles (pulvinar, ligamentum teres, capsule)
- Cannot perform capsulorrhaphy
- Cannot perform pelvic osteotomy simultaneously
- Used for straightforward open reductions in younger infants
B. Anterior (Anterolateral / Smith-Petersen) Approach — >9–12 months
- Between tensor fascia lata (sup. gluteal nerve) and sartorius/rectus femoris (femoral nerve)
- Preferred for older children
- Allows:
- Complete visualization and removal of all obstacles
- Capsulorrhaphy (tightening of redundant capsule — critical for stability)
- Simultaneous pelvic osteotomy
- Internervous plane: TFL (sup. gluteal n.) / Sartorius (femoral n.)
6. Femoral Osteotomy
Indications:
- Excessive anteversion (>40°) causing instability
- Coxa valga (neck-shaft angle >150°)
- Needed to shorten femur (in late cases — reduces pressure on femoral head, lowers AVN risk)
Types:
| Osteotomy | What it corrects | Notes |
|---|
| Derotation osteotomy | Excessive anteversion | Most common; brings femoral head forward into acetabulum |
| Varus osteotomy | Coxa valga | Reduces neck-shaft angle to ~120–130° |
| Shortening osteotomy | Limb length + reduces tension | Essential in children >2–3 years; prevents AVN from forceful reduction |
- Performed at the subtrochanteric or intertrochanteric level
- Fixed with a blade plate, DCP, or pediatric hip screw
- Often combined with pelvic osteotomy (triple procedure)
7. Pelvic Osteotomies
Required when acetabulum remains dysplastic (shallow, steep) despite femoral head reduction.
Salter Innominate Osteotomy (most commonly discussed)
- Age: 18 months – 6 years (open triradiate cartilage required)
- Mechanism: Single cut through ilium above acetabulum; acetabulum rotated anterolaterally as a unit; bone graft (from iliac crest) holds correction
- Corrects: Anterior and lateral deficiency of coverage
- Limitation: Cannot increase overall acetabular volume
Pemberton Osteotomy
- Incomplete (hinge) osteotomy through ilium curving to triradiate cartilage
- Bends acetabular roof downward — reduces acetabular volume (good for large femoral head coverage)
- Requires open triradiate cartilage as a hinge
Dega Osteotomy
- Similar to Pemberton but hinge is more posterior
- Popular in neuromuscular hip dysplasia (cerebral palsy)
- Good posterior coverage
Triple Pelvic Osteotomy (Steel/Tönnis) — older children with closed triradiate
- Cuts through ilium, ischium, and pubis
- Full mobilization of acetabular fragment
- Used when triradiate cartilage closed (>8 years)
Chiari Osteotomy — salvage
- Medial displacement of ilium above hip joint
- Does not redirect acetabulum; creates a shelf of ilium for coverage
- Used when redirectional osteotomies not possible (older, deformed acetabulum)
Comparison Summary:
| Osteotomy | Age | Triradiate | Mechanism | Best for |
|---|
| Salter | 18m–6y | Open | Rotates acetabulum anterolaterally | Anterior + lateral deficiency |
| Pemberton | 18m–8y | Open (hinge) | Tilts roof down, reduces volume | Large femoral heads |
| Dega | 18m–8y | Open | Posterior tilt | Neuromuscular dysplasia |
| Triple (Steel) | >8y | Closed | Full acetabular mobilization | Older child/adolescent |
| Chiari | Any | Any | Medialization shelf | Salvage |
8. The Combined / Triple Procedure
In children >2 years, the standard surgical approach is the "triple procedure":
Open Reduction (anterior approach)
+
Femoral Osteotomy (derotation + varus + shortening)
+
Pelvic Osteotomy (Salter or Pemberton)
All performed in a single anaesthetic sitting to:
- Minimise number of GA exposures in children
- Allow simultaneous correction of all deformities
- Improve overall surgical outcome
(Bailey & Love's Surgery, 28th Ed., p. 639)
9. Post-operative Protocol (Surgical)
| Phase | Management |
|---|
| Immediate post-op | Hip spica cast (4–6 weeks), neurovascular monitoring |
| Cast removal | Under GA; check X-ray/MRI for reduction quality |
| Rehabilitation | Physiotherapy — hip ROM, muscle strengthening |
| Hardware removal | Plates/screws removed after osteotomy healed (6–12 months) |
| Follow-up | Until skeletal maturity (to monitor for AVN, residual dysplasia, remodeling) |
10. Complications — Surgical Perspective
Avascular Necrosis (AVN) of Femoral Head — Most Critical
- Caused by: forceful reduction, extreme abduction, surgical insult to blood supply
- Blood supply to femoral head: medial circumflex femoral artery (main) → retinacular vessels
- Kalamchi & MacEwen Classification:
| Grade | Description | Outcome |
|---|
| I | Lateral epiphyseal damage only | Mild; usually remodels |
| II | Central epiphyseal arrest | Shortened femoral neck |
| III | Lateral physeal arrest | Coxa breva + greater trochanter overgrowth |
| IV | Total epiphyseal ischaemia | Severe deformity, poor prognosis |
Other Surgical Complications:
| Complication | Cause | Management |
|---|
| Redislocation | Poor capsulorrhaphy, inadequate soft tissue release | Reoperation |
| Residual dysplasia | Insufficient acetabular remodeling | Secondary osteotomy |
| Femoral nerve injury | Anterior approach retraction | Careful dissection, usually transient |
| Infection | Deep surgical site | Antibiotics ± washout |
| Implant failure | Hardware loosening in osteotomy | Revision fixation |
| Stiffness | Prolonged immobilization | Physiotherapy |
| Leg length discrepancy | Physeal damage from AVN | Epiphysiodesis / limb lengthening |
| Early osteoarthritis | Residual dysplasia / AVN | THR in adulthood |
11. Surgical Outcomes — Prognostic Factors
| Better Outcome | Worse Outcome |
|---|
| Early diagnosis (<6 months) | Late diagnosis (>2 years) |
| Unilateral | Bilateral |
| Concentric reduction achieved | Redislocation / AVN |
| Normal acetabular index by age 2 | Persistent steep acetabulum |
| No AVN | AVN Grade III–IV |
| Adequate soft tissue release | Residual instability |
Key prognostic milestone: If the acetabular index normalises to <25° by age 2, the outcome is likely excellent with no further intervention required.
12. Key Surgical Discussion Points for the Committee
-
Why do we prefer anterior over medial approach in children >12 months?
→ Allows capsulorrhaphy + simultaneous pelvic osteotomy in one sitting
-
What is the "safe zone" and why does it matter intraoperatively?
→ Determines feasibility of closed reduction; narrow safe zone = proceed to open
-
Why is femoral shortening osteotomy critical in late-presenting cases?
→ Reduces lever arm tension on femoral head → prevents AVN
-
What is Pavlik disease and how do we avoid it?
→ Abandon harness if no reduction in 3–4 weeks; posterior acetabular erosion
-
When do you choose Pemberton over Salter?
→ Pemberton when femoral head is large relative to acetabulum and you need to reduce volume, not just redirect
-
What is the single most feared complication and why?
→ AVN — irreversible, leads to femoral head collapse and lifetime disability
This covers DDH from a full paediatric surgical standpoint. If you want, I can go further into any specific operative technique, draw the osteotomy diagrams, or cover a surgical case scenario for the committee!