I now have comprehensive content from the textbooks. Let me compile the complete, well-organized answer.
Hip Dislocations and Displaced Fractures of the Hip
PART 1 - HIP DISLOCATIONS
Overview
Native hip dislocations result from high-energy trauma, and up to 95% of patients have associated injuries. Motor vehicle collisions (particularly dashboard injuries) are the most common mechanism. Dislocations of prosthetic hips can occur with minimal trauma.
- Posterior dislocations: >90% of all hip dislocations
- Anterior dislocations: ~10% (superior/pubic or inferior/obturator)
Hip dislocation is an orthopaedic emergency. Reduction should occur within 6 hours. AVN risk rises from <10% at <10 hours to ~25% when delay extends to 15 hours.
Posterior hip dislocation - schematic view (Tintinalli's Emergency Medicine)
Anatomy of Dislocation
For any hip to dislocate, the ligamentum teres and at least part of the capsule must be disrupted. Labral tears/avulsions and muscular injury are common.
- Posterior dislocations: Capsule torn posteriorly or inferoposteriorly. The Y ligament (iliofemoral) is generally intact but stripped from its acetabular attachment.
- Anterior dislocations: The psoas acts as a fulcrum; capsule is disrupted anteroinferiorly. Femoral vessel injury, though rare, can occur in high-energy injuries.
1A. Posterior Hip Dislocation
Mechanism: Posterior force on a flexed knee - the classic "dashboard injury."
Clinical presentation:
- Limb shortened, adducted, and internally rotated (key distinguishing feature from femoral neck fracture, which is externally rotated)
- Associated injuries: acetabular fracture, femoral neck fracture, femoral shaft fracture, knee ligament injury
- Sciatic nerve injury in ~10% of cases
Imaging:
- AP + lateral pelvis radiograph
- CT of acetabulum and femur after identification
AP pelvis X-ray: right-sided posterior hip dislocation with acetabular fracture (Tintinalli's)
Reduction techniques (closed, with procedural sedation):
- Allis maneuver (most common): In-line traction with simultaneous hip flexion and internal rotation
- Multiple techniques described; EM physician should be proficient in more than one
- Anterior dislocations require OR reduction
Classification of Posterior Hip Dislocations
Thompson and Epstein Classification:
| Type | Description |
|---|
| I | Dislocation with or without minor fracture |
| II | Dislocation with single large fragment of posterior acetabular rim |
| III | Dislocation with comminuted rim fracture |
| IV | Dislocation with fracture of the acetabular floor |
| V | Dislocation with fracture of the femoral head |
Stewart and Milford Classification (addresses postreduction stability):
| Type | Description |
|---|
| I | Simple dislocation without fracture |
| II | One or more rim fragments; socket sufficient for stability after reduction |
| III | Rim fracture producing gross instability |
| IV | Dislocation with fracture of the head or neck of femur |
Pipkin Classification (for Type V Thompson/Epstein - femoral head fracture):
| Type | Description |
|---|
| I | Posterior dislocation with femoral head fracture caudad to the fovea |
| II | Posterior dislocation with femoral head fracture cephalad to the fovea |
| III | Femoral head fracture with associated femoral neck fracture |
| IV | Types I or II combined with acetabular fracture |
Brumback Classification (comprehensive, includes anterior and central):
Brumback classification of hip dislocations with femoral head fractures (Rockwood & Green's, 10th Ed.)
| Type | Description |
|---|
| 1A | Posterior dislocation + inferomedial femoral head fracture, minimum acetabular rim fracture, stable after reduction |
| 1B | Same with significant acetabular rim fracture |
| 2A | Posterior dislocation + superomedial femoral head fracture, stable |
| 2B | Same with significant acetabular fracture and instability |
| 3A/3B | Dislocation (any direction) + femoral neck fracture, without/with femoral head fracture |
| 4A | Anterior dislocation, indentation type (superolateral depression) |
| 4B | Anterior dislocation, transchondral shear fracture |
| 5 | Central fracture-dislocation with femoral head fracture |
1B. Anterior Hip Dislocation
Mechanism: Forced abduction levers the femoral head anteriorly through a capsular tear.
- Superior (pubic/subspinous): Hip extended at time of injury
- Inferior (obturator): Hip flexed at time of injury
Clinical presentation:
- Limb in abduction and external rotation (opposite of posterior)
- Femoral artery or nerve injury possible - full neurovascular exam required
Left: anterior superior dislocation. Right: anterior inferior (obturator) dislocation (Tintinalli's)
Management: Anterior hip dislocations mandate reduction in the OR under general anesthesia.
Indications for Open Reduction
- Failed closed reduction
- Unsatisfactory reduction
- Complex fracture-dislocations
- Irreducible dislocations
PART 2 - DISPLACED FRACTURES OF THE HIP
Anatomy of Fracture Sites
Proximal femoral fracture sites with intracapsular vs. extracapsular zones (Grainger & Allison's)
Key distinction:
| Zone | Fracture Types | AVN Risk |
|---|
| Intracapsular | Subcapital, transcervical, basicervical | HIGH (blood supply to femoral head at risk) |
| Extracapsular | Intertrochanteric, subtrochanteric | Lower (blood supply preserved) |
2A. Femoral Neck Fractures (Intracapsular)
The blood supply to the femoral head runs via recurrent arteries closely applied to the femoral neck. Displaced intracapsular fractures disrupt this supply.
- AVN risk: 15-35% with displaced intracapsular fractures
- ~15% of fractures are radiographically subtle initially
- Occult fractures: if weight-bearing is limited at 24 hours, MRI is the investigation of choice (specific and sensitive)
Garden Classification of Intracapsular Fractures:
Garden Classification (Grainger & Allison's Diagnostic Radiology)
| Stage | Description |
|---|
| 1 | Undisplaced incomplete (including valgus impaction) |
| 2 | Complete fracture, no displacement |
| 3 | Complete fracture, varus angulation |
| 4 | Completely displaced |
Garden 3 and 4 carry the highest AVN risk as the blood supply is almost inevitably interrupted (particularly in displaced subcapital fractures).
Treatment:
- Garden 1 & 2 (undisplaced): Internal fixation with dynamic hip screw or multiple cannulated screws (especially in patients <60 who were independently mobile)
- Garden 3 & 4 (displaced): Hemiarthroplasty; or total hip replacement in patients who were independently mobile before fracture
- Interruption of trabecular lines on X-ray = subtle fracture; use lateral view and MRI to confirm
2B. Intertrochanteric Fractures (Extracapsular)
- Run between the greater and lesser trochanters
- Blood supply is preserved - lower AVN risk
- Can be treated with plate and dynamic screw fixation or intramedullary nailing
- Severely comminuted fractures are easily identified on X-ray
- Subtle/minimally displaced fractures may be missed - air trapped in skin crease of groin can mimic or mask a fracture
- Approximately 1% are initially occult on plain X-ray; if not detected and patient mobilizes, fracture may displace
2C. Subtrochanteric Fractures (Extracapsular)
- Below the lesser trochanter, extracapsular
- Treated by intramedullary nailing
- Lower AVN risk compared to intracapsular fractures
PART 3 - COMPLICATIONS
| Complication | Associated With | Timing |
|---|
| Avascular necrosis (AVN) | Posterior dislocation; displaced subcapital fractures | Weeks-months |
| Sciatic nerve injury | Posterior dislocation | Acute (~10%) |
| Femoral nerve/artery injury | Anterior dislocation | Acute |
| Post-traumatic arthritis | Any fracture-dislocation | Late |
| Fracture displacement | Occult undisplaced fractures if mobilized | Early |
- AVN risk from hip dislocation increases from <10% at <10 hours delay to ~25% at 15 hours delay
- Outcomes are measured with Harris Hip Score, WOMAC, and Merle d'Aubigne scores; overall health with SF-12 and SMFA
Summary Table
| Injury | Mechanism | Position of Limb | Key Complication | Treatment |
|---|
| Posterior dislocation | Dashboard (flexed knee) | Short, adducted, internally rotated | AVN, sciatic nerve injury | Closed reduction (6 hrs), OR if failed |
| Anterior dislocation | Forced abduction | Abducted, externally rotated | Femoral nerve/vessel | Open reduction in OR |
| Displaced subcapital (Garden 3/4) | Low-energy fall (elderly) | Externally rotated, shortened | AVN (15-35%) | Hemiarthroplasty or THA |
| Undisplaced femoral neck (Garden 1/2) | Variable | May be minimal | Fracture displacement if missed | Internal fixation |
| Intertrochanteric | Low energy (elderly) | Externally rotated | Less AVN risk | DHS or IMN |
| Subtrochanteric | High energy | Variable | Deformity, delayed union | IMN |
Sources: Tintinalli's Emergency Medicine (9th Ed.) - pp. 1888-1891; Rockwood & Green's Fractures in Adults (10th Ed. 2025) - pp. 2574-2579; Grainger & Allison's Diagnostic Radiology - pp. 1162-1163; Roberts & Hedges' Clinical Procedures in Emergency Medicine.