---

How to Tell If Pain Is Coming From Bone, Muscle, Tendon, or Ligament - and How to Treat It

---

1. Bone Pain

How It Feels

• Deep, boring, or aching pain that persists at rest - this is the hallmark
• Does NOT go away with immobilization the way soft tissue pain does
• Often worse at night and independent of movement
• Can be diffuse or localized over a bony area

Key Clues

• Direct tenderness over bone on palpation (e.g., pressing directly on the tibia or a rib causes pain)
• Point tenderness over a specific bony site after trauma suggests fracture
• No relief with stretching or massaging the area
• Pain reproduced by axial loading (pressing along the axis of the bone)
• In children: localized bone pain + fever = rule out osteomyelitis

Causes

• Fracture (acute trauma)
• Stress fracture (repetitive loading - pain during and after activity)
• Bone infection (osteomyelitis)
• Bone tumors or metastases (night pain, no trauma history)
• Metabolic bone disease (osteoporosis, Paget's disease)

Investigations

• X-ray (first line, but misses stress fractures early)
• MRI - best for occult fractures, bone marrow involvement
• Bone scan - sensitive for stress fractures and metastases

Treatment

From Textbook of Family Medicine 9e: "NSAIDs are quite helpful in alleviating pain from lesions in bones or skeletal muscles. The COX-2 inhibitor celecoxib offers comparable analgesia with less GI toxicity."

---

2. Muscle Pain (Strain)

How It Feels

• Diffuse, dull ache spread over a broader area - not pinpoint
• Pain is worse with active use (when you contract or use the muscle)
• Typically does NOT hurt with passive movement (when someone else moves your limb without you engaging the muscle)
• Tender over the belly of the muscle, not at the joint
• Often "tight" or crampy sensation

Key Clues

• Pain increases when the muscle is contracted against resistance
• Stretching the muscle reproduces or worsens pain
• Palpation of the muscle belly causes tenderness (not joint line)
• Ecchymosis (bruising) and swelling in moderate-severe tears
• A "pop" felt at time of injury suggests tear

Grading of Muscle Strains

• Grade 1: Minor tearing - minor swelling, local tenderness, minimal restriction
• Grade 2: More tearing, no complete disruption - swelling, ecchymosis, loss of strength
• Grade 3: Complete disruption - separation of muscle from tendon or bone, severe weakness

Causes

• Sudden forceful contraction or excessive stretch ("pulled muscle")
• Overuse, fatigue
• Direct trauma (contusion)

Investigations

• Clinical diagnosis usually sufficient
• Ultrasound or MRI for grade 2-3 tears to assess extent

Treatment

---

3. Tendon Pain (Tendinitis / Tendinopathy)

How It Feels

• Pinpoint, sharp or burning pain localized directly over the tendon (not diffuse)
• Pain is felt where the muscle meets the bone (at the tendon insertion)
• "Tennis elbow" hurts at the lateral epicondyle - that spot where the muscle inserts
• Burning sensation is the classic descriptor
• Worsens with activity, improves initially with warm-up ("warm-up phenomenon")

Key Clues

• Resisted movement reproduces the pain - hold the limb still and ask patient to push against you (resisted contraction)
• Pain is at the end range of stretch (when the tendon is maximally loaded)
• Direct palpation exactly over the tendon reproduces pinpoint pain
• No significant joint instability

Common Sites

• Shoulder rotator cuff, Achilles tendon, patellar tendon (jumper's knee), lateral epicondyle (tennis elbow), medial epicondyle (golfer's elbow), de Quervain's (thumb side of wrist), posterior tibial tendon

Causes

Investigations

• X-ray: usually negative; may show calcium deposits (calcific tendinitis)
• Ultrasound: excellent for tendon thickening, tears, calcification
• MRI: for partial/full tears

Treatment

Per Rosen's: "NSAIDs may be useful for a brief period as an analgesic but have not been demonstrated to significantly alter the pathophysiology."

---

4. Ligament Pain (Sprain)

How It Feels

• Localized to a joint, often with immediate sharp pain at time of injury
• Instability or "giving way" sensation at the joint
• Swelling develops around the joint (not over a muscle belly)
• Pain with passive movement (someone else moving your joint) - this is the key differentiator from muscle pain
• Pain at the end of joint range of motion

Key Clues

• Pain is reproduced by stressing the ligament - valgus/varus stress tests for the knee, anterior drawer for the ankle
• Joint line tenderness rather than bone or muscle belly tenderness
• History of twisting, rolling, or sudden direction change
• Hemarthrosis (blood in the joint) suggests significant ligamentous injury, especially ACL tear
• Passive range of motion reproduces pain even without muscle activation

Grading of Sprains (Ligament)

• Grade 1: Ligament stretched, not torn - mild tenderness, minimal swelling, no instability
• Grade 2: Partial tear - moderate swelling, tenderness, some instability
• Grade 3: Complete tear - marked swelling, significant instability, loss of function

Investigations

• X-ray: rules out associated avulsion fracture
• MRI: best for confirming degree of ligamentous tear, especially knee (ACL, MCL, PCL)
• Note: In children, epiphyseal fractures are MORE common than ligament tears

Treatment

Per Rosen's: "Ligaments are relatively avascular, healing is slow, and patients with significant sprains should be informed of this. Sprains should not be trivialized."

---

Quick Comparison Table

---

Red Flags - See a Doctor Immediately

• Bone pain after trauma with inability to bear weight (possible fracture)
• Bone pain without injury + night pain + weight loss (rule out tumor or metastases)
• Severe swelling, immediate bruising, complete loss of function (Grade 3 tear)
• A palpable gap or "pop" heard at time of injury
• Joint hemarthrosis (knee filled with blood after injury - possible ACL tear)
• Fever with bone or joint pain (infection)
• Children with bone pain + fever (osteomyelitis)

---

Osteoarthritis vs. Osteoporosis - Complete Comparison with Treatment

---

THE CORE DISTINCTION

---

PART 1: OSTEOARTHRITIS (OA)

Definition

• Goldman-Cecil Medicine: "The resulting breakdown of cartilage and bone can lead to symptoms of pain, stiffness, and functional disability. However, synovial joint pathology and structural changes on imaging may correlate poorly with patient-reported symptoms."

Epidemiology

• Affects >50 million people worldwide; women disproportionately affected
• Prevalence rises exponentially after age 50; ~40% of people over 70 are affected
• Primary OA (idiopathic): appears without cause, as an aging phenomenon - oligoarticular, affecting weight-bearing joints
• Secondary OA (~5% of cases): occurs in younger people with joint deformity, prior injury, diabetes, or obesity

Pathogenesis

1. Chondrocyte injury - mechanical/genetic insult damages chondrocytes and the extracellular matrix (Type II collagen, proteoglycans)
2. Early OA - chondrocytes proliferate and attempt repair, releasing BMPs (bone morphogenetic proteins) for repair, but also MMPs (matrix metalloproteinases), PGE2, NO, and TNF that degrade collagen and proteoglycans faster than they can be repaired
3. Late OA - chondrocyte dropout, apoptosis, full-thickness cartilage loss, subchondral bone damage, osteophyte formation, loose bodies ("joint mice")

Morphology / Pathology

Clinical Features

• Joint pain - worsens with use, improves with rest (early) or persists at rest (late = "night pain" = surgical indication)
• Morning stiffness - brief, typically <30 minutes (unlike RA >1 hour)
• Crepitus - grinding or clicking with movement
• Limited range of motion
• Bony enlargement - osteophytes palpable at joint margins
• Heberden nodes (osteophytes at DIP joints) and Bouchard nodes (PIP joints) - more common in women
• No systemic features (no fever, no weight loss, no fatigue)
• Spinal OA: osteophytes compressing nerve roots cause radicular pain, muscle spasms, atrophy, neurological deficits

Joints Commonly Involved

• Hips, knees (weight-bearing - most symptomatic)
• Lower lumbar and cervical vertebrae
• DIP and PIP joints of fingers
• First carpometacarpal joint (base of thumb)
• First tarsometatarsal joint (base of big toe)
• NOT typically: wrists, MCPs, ankles (these suggest inflammatory arthritis)

Diagnosis

Treatment of Osteoarthritis

Non-Pharmacological (First Line)

Pharmacological

From Rosen's Emergency Medicine: "There are no treatments to prevent or halt the progression of OA. Therapies include pain management, NSAIDs to reduce inflammation, intra-articular corticosteroids, activity modification, and, for severe cases, joint replacement."

Surgical Treatment

---

PART 2: OSTEOPOROSIS

Definition

• Bone strength = BMD (bone mineral density) + bone quality (architecture, turnover, mineralization, micro-damage)
• WHO Definition by T-score (BMD measured by DXA, compared to young healthy reference):
  • Normal: T-score ≥ -1.0
  • Osteopenia: T-score between -1.0 and -2.5
  • Osteoporosis: T-score ≤ -2.5
  • Severe osteoporosis: T-score ≤ -2.5 + fragility fracture

Epidemiology

• Most common metabolic bone disease
• ~50% of women and 20% of men over age 50 will have a fragility fracture in their lifetime (Caucasian populations)
• The elderly are the fastest-growing age group; yearly fragility fractures will increase substantially
• One fragility fracture dramatically increases the risk of future fractures: vertebral fracture → hip fracture risk ×2, vertebral fracture risk ×5

Pathogenesis

Main Causes of Osteoporosis

• Postmenopausal (type I)
• Senile/age-related (type II)
• Idiopathic

• Endocrine: hyperparathyroidism, hyperthyroidism, Cushing's syndrome, hypogonadism, diabetes mellitus
• Drugs: glucocorticoids (most common), heparin, anticonvulsants, proton pump inhibitors, aromatase inhibitors
• Nutritional: calcium/vitamin D deficiency, malabsorption, anorexia nervosa
• Inflammatory: rheumatoid arthritis, IBD
• Immobilization

Clinical Features

Fractures - The Clinical Presentation

Red Flags for Vertebral Fractures

• Fractures above T7: think metastases (osteoporotic fractures rare above T7)
• Posterior vertebral body fracture: think metastases or myeloma (not typical of osteoporosis)
• Pain that does NOT resolve in 6-8 weeks: metastases vs. osteoporosis

Diagnosis

Treatment of Osteoporosis

Non-Pharmacological (For ALL Patients)

Pharmacological - Anti-Resorptive Agents

Pharmacological - Anabolic (Bone-Building) Agents

From Swanson's Family Medicine: "Bisphosphonates - demonstrated efficacy for vertebral fracture reduction; alendronate and risedronate for non-vertebral and hip fracture reduction as well." Teriparatide and denosumab - both demonstrated efficacy for vertebral AND non-vertebral fracture reduction.

Surgical Options (for Fractures)

From Grainger & Allison's Diagnostic Radiology: "Patients with proven osteoporosis should always be commenced on bone protective/bone enhancing therapy when vertebroplasty is performed."

---

SIDE-BY-SIDE COMPARISON TABLE

---

A Note on Co-existence

---