---

---

Types of Offences - Forensic Medicine (Narayan Reddy)

Definition of Offence

---

Classification of Offences

1. Cognizable vs Non-Cognizable
2. Bailable vs Non-Bailable
3. Compoundable vs Non-Compoundable
4. Summons Case vs Warrant Case

---

1. Cognizable vs Non-Cognizable Offences

Cognizable Offence

Non-Cognizable Offence

---

Comparison Table: Cognizable vs Non-Cognizable

---

2. Bailable vs Non-Bailable Offences

Bailable Offence

• The accused has a right to demand bail as a matter of right.
• Bail cannot be refused by police or Magistrate.
• These are generally less serious offences.
• Examples: Simple hurt, mischief, negligent acts.

Non-Bailable Offence

• Bail is not a right - it can only be granted by the court at its discretion.
• Police officer cannot grant bail for non-bailable offences.
• Examples: Murder, rape, dacoity, kidnapping, dowry death.
• Under Section 437, BNSS (S. 437, Cr.P.C.) - Magistrate may grant bail with conditions.
• Under Section 439, BNSS (S. 439, Cr.P.C.) - High Court / Sessions Court can grant bail.

---

3. Compoundable vs Non-Compoundable Offences

Compoundable Offence

• The complainant (victim) and accused can arrive at a settlement (compromise).
• The complainant can withdraw the complaint with the court's permission.
• Two types:
  • With Court's permission: e.g., causing grievous hurt
  • Without Court's permission: e.g., simple hurt, defamation (private matters)

Non-Compoundable Offence

• Cannot be settled between the parties.
• The state continues prosecution even if the victim forgives.
• Examples: Murder, rape, dacoity - these are crimes against the state, not just the individual.

---

4. Summons Case vs Warrant Case

---

Key Points for Forensic Medicine Exam (Narayan Reddy Points)

1. Cognizable offence is listed as a short note topic in Narayan Reddy (Short Notes section, Block 1).
2. All medicolegal cases (MLCs) seen by doctors - injuries due to assault, rape, acid attack, dowry death, unnatural death - involve cognizable offences and require FIR registration.
3. The doctor examining a victim of rape or assault is dealing with evidence in a cognizable, non-bailable offence - this makes accurate documentation critical.
4. FIR (First Information Report) is mandatory in cognizable offences - the doctor may be the first person to suspect foul play and must inform police promptly.
5. Under BNSS 2023 (new law replacing Cr.P.C.), these definitions and schedules remain essentially the same but the section numbers have changed.

---

Quick Mnemonics

• Cognizable = Constable can arrest (no warrant needed)
• Non-cognizable = Need warrant
• Bailable = Bail as a right
• Non-bailable = Not automatic - court decides

---

---

Legal Importance of Documentation / Preservation of Medico-Legal Records

The Essentials of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology, 36th Edition (Narayan Reddy, 2026) - Chapter 3

---

What are Medical Records?

---

Objectives / Purposes of Medical Records (Narayan Reddy)

1. To serve as the basis for patient's care and continuity of evaluation and treatment.
2. To serve as documentation for reimbursement (insurance, etc.).
3. To provide data for medical education and clinical research.
4. To document communication between the treating doctor and other healthcare professionals contributing to care.
5. To protect the legal interests of the patient, the hospital, and the practitioner responsible for patient care.
6. To assist in follow-up of patients, evaluation of drug therapy, and cost accounting.
7. Medical records may be required in cases of:
   • Professional negligence
   • Claims under health and accident insurance
   • Life insurance policies
   • Disability policies
   • Accidental deaths
   • Workmen's Compensation Act
   • Traffic accidents

---

Mandatory Information to be Documented

---

Golden Rules for Maintaining Medical Records

"Accurate, Appropriate, Chronological, Factual, Relevant and Complete" - Narayan Reddy

1. No tampering - Nothing should be altered, deleted, substituted, or added.
   • If tampering is done, the patient may be awarded large sums even if there was no negligence.
2. If a correction must be made - draw a single line through the word, write correct information above it with the date and signature/initials of the person making the change + reason for change.
3. Omission of essential details may cast doubt on the truthfulness of the witness (doctor).
4. Good notes have great value when handing a patient over to another doctor and in meeting any criticism.
5. When there is conflict of evidence, the court will attach importance to notes written at the time of examination.
6. If a patient refuses advice, this fact should be recorded in writing.

---

Preservation Periods for Medical Records (Medical Council Regulations)

---

Rights and Confidentiality Rules

1. The patient has the right to know what is in his/her records.
2. Patient is entitled to a brief report of hospital record on discharge.
3. Next of kin can get the record in case of patient's death.
4. The hospital must maintain confidentiality of records.
5. Police do not have a right to demand medical records except when there is statutory provision (e.g., court order).
6. Records cannot be used in educational conferences, clinics, or publications without the patient's consent.
7. Hospitals may use medical records (without patient consent) for statistical purposes and quality of care determinations.
8. X-ray plates are the property of the treating doctor - the patient buys the skill and treatment, not the X-ray films.
9. If disclosure would be harmful to the patient (therapeutic/professional discretion), the hospital can avoid issuing the record.

---

Wound Certificate and Accident Register (Medico-Legal Records)

Accident Register

• Maintained in all hospitals including clinics and nursing homes.
• All details of examination of injured persons (whether admitted or OPD) must be entered.
• It is a confidential record and kept in safe custody of the medical officer.
• Must be produced in a Court of law if asked for.

Wound Certificate Format - Mandatory Entries

1. Serial number of case
2. Name, age, sex, address of injured person
3. Father's / guardian's name
4. Date, time, and place of examination
5. Name and number of accompanying police constable and police station
6. Names of accompanying persons with addresses
7. Brief statement of injured person about nature of incident - recorded as "alleged by the patient"
8. Two identification marks
9. Stature, body weight, development of victim
10. Consent of person for examination; if serious - dying declaration to be recorded

1. Type of each injury - abrasion, contusion, incised wound, lacerated wound, stab wound, burns, fracture, dislocation
2. Size - length x breadth x depth (in cms)
3. Location - on the body surface with exact anatomical site
4. Age of injury - fresh, recent, or old
5. Weapon likely to have caused the injury
6. Whether injury is simple or grievous (to guide the investigating officer)
7. General condition of the patient
8. One copy sent to investigating police officer in sealed cover, other copy retained for future reference.

---

Medical Council of India / NMC Regulations on Medical Records (Narayan Reddy)

• Maintain a register of medical certificates giving full details, with signature of patients and at least one identification mark.
• Maintain medical records pertaining to indoor patients for a period of 3 years from the date of completion.
• Medico-legally important records preserved for 10 years.

---

Legal Consequences of Poor Documentation

---

Summary of Legal Importance (Key Points for Exam)

1. Medical records are the only objective evidence of what was done clinically.
2. In negligence cases, courts rely almost entirely on records - "If it's not written, it wasn't done."
3. The Accident Register is a primary legal document in medico-legal cases.
4. Wound certificate guides the police and courts on the nature and gravity of assault.
5. Records protect both the patient's interests (fair trial, compensation) and the doctor's interests (defence against false claims).
6. Preservation for defined periods ensures records are available for litigation, which may arise years later.
7. Any tampering with records is one of the gravest professional misconduct acts and can be penalised severely.

---

---

First Information Report (FIR) & Documentary Evidence

The Essentials of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology, 36th Edition - K.S. Narayan Reddy (2026)

---

FIRST INFORMATION REPORT (FIR)

Definition

Key Features of FIR

Importance of FIR in Forensic Medicine

1. Triggers medical examination - once FIR is registered, police send the victim/accused to a doctor with a requisition letter.
2. Acts as the primary document linking a medicolegal case to the criminal justice system.
3. Provides the nature of the alleged offence to the doctor - guiding what type of examination to conduct (e.g., rape examination vs. assault).
4. In non-cognizable offences (Section 2(l), BNSS), the injured person may go directly to the doctor OR file an affidavit before a Magistrate who then sends him for examination (Section 35, BNSS / S.41, Cr.P.C.).
5. The FIR is a public document and is admissible in court.

FIR vs. Non-Cognizable Report (NCR)

---

MEDICAL EVIDENCE

1. All statements which the court permits or requires to be made before it by witnesses in relation to matters of fact under inquiry.
2. All documents produced for the inspection of the court [Section 2, BNS].
3. Evidence of an eyewitness is positive; evidence of a doctor/expert is only an opinion which is corroborative.

Types of Evidence

EVIDENCE
├── Documentary Evidence  ← (our topic)
└── Oral Evidence
    ├── Direct
    ├── Indirect / Circumstantial
    └── Hearsay

---

DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE (Narayan Reddy - 3 Types)

• Primary evidence = The document itself produced for inspection of the court [Section 208, BNS / Section 59, BSA]
• Secondary evidence = Certified copies, copies made from original by mechanical processes, oral account of document contents [Section 58, BSA]

Type 1 - MEDICAL CERTIFICATES

Type 2 - MEDICO-LEGAL REPORTS (MLR)

Type 3 - DYING DECLARATION

---

Summary Table for 5-Mark Answer

---

Key Points for Exam (5-marker)

1. FIR applies only to cognizable offences and sets criminal proceedings in motion.
2. Documentary evidence in forensic medicine has 3 types - remember: "MCM" (Medical Certificates, MLR, Dying Declaration).
3. Medical certificates must be preserved for 2 years (duplicate); a false certificate is punishable under S.234 BNS.
4. MLR must be written in duplicate - first to IO, second retained by doctor - and requires doctor's court attendance for admissibility.
5. Dying declaration is the most powerful of the three - can convict even without other evidence.

---