Yes, that's correct. Itching (pruritus) is a known but uncommon side effect of methenamine hippurate, usually along with a rash.
Recent evidence check
PubMed returned three recent systematic reviews, including a
2025 meta-analysis of randomized trials in UTI prevention, plus 2024 reviews (PMIDs 38329493 and 37986168). I only read the titles, not the abstracts. Nothing I found suggests the safety profile above has changed. I did not check these reviews' tolerability data.
If you're asking about a specific patient, tell me the timing and any other symptoms and I can help think it through.